第1章

类别:其他 作者:Sir Joshua Reynolds字数:23537更新时间:19/01/03 14:03:25
INTRODUCTION ItisahappymemorythatassociatesthefoundationofourRoyalAcademywiththedeliveryoftheseinauguraldiscoursesbySirJoshuaReynolds,ontheopeningoftheschools,andatthefirstannualmeetingsforthedistributionofitsprizes。Theylaiddownprinciplesofartfromthepointofviewofamanofgeniuswhohadmadehispowerfelt,andwiththecleargoodsensewhichisthefoundationofallworkthatlooksupwardandmayhopetolive。ThetruthshereexpressedconcerningArtmay,withslightadjustmentofthewayofthought,beappliedtoLiteratureortoanyexerciseofthebestpowersofmindforshapingthedelightsthatraiseustothelargersenseoflife。Inhisseparationoftheutteranceofwholetruthsfrominsistanceuponaccidentsofdetail,Reynoldswasright,becauseheguardedtheexpressionofhisviewwithcarefuldefinitionsofitslimits。InthesamewayBoileauwasright,asacriticofLiterature,indemandingeverywheregoodsense,incondemningthepastebrilliantsofastylethenindecay,andfixingattentionuponthemasterlysimplicityofRomanpoetsinthetimeofAugustus。CriticsbyruleofthumbreducedtheprinciplesclearlydefinedbyBoileautoadullconvention,againstwhichtherecameincourseoftimeastrongreaction。InlikemannertheteachingofReynoldswasappliedbydullmentomuchvagueandconventionalgeneralisationinthenameofdignity。Nevertheless,ReynoldstaughtessentialtruthsofArt。Theprincipleslaiddownbyhimwillneverfailtogivestrengthtotherightartist,ortrueguidancetowardstheappreciationofgoodart,thoughhereandtherewemaynotwhollyassenttosomepassingapplicationofthem,wherethedifferencemaybegreatbetweenafashionofthoughtinhistimeandinours。Arighteousenforcementofexacttruthinourdayhasledmanyintoareadinesstoappreciatemorereallytheminuteimitationofasatindress,oraredherring,thanthenoblestfigureinthebestofRaffaelle’scartoons。Muchgoodshouldcomeofthediffusionofthiswiselittlebook。 JoshuaReynoldswasbornonthe15thofJuly,1723,thesonofaclergymanandschoolmaster,atPlymptoninDevonshire。HisbentforArtwasclearandstrongfromhischildhood。In1741attheageofnineteen,hebeganstudy,andstudiedfortwoyoursinLondonunderThomasHudson,asuccessfulportraitpainter。ThenhewentbacktoDevonshireandpaintedportraits,aidedforsometimeinhiseducationbyattentiontotheworkofWilliamGandyofExeter。Whentwenty-sixyearsold,inMay,1749,ReynoldswastakenawaybyCaptainKeppeltotheMediterranean,andbroughtintocontactwiththeworksofthegreatpaintersofItaly。HestayedtwoyearsinRome,andinaccordancewiththeprinciplesafterwardslaiddownintheselectures,herefused,wheninRome,commissionsforcopying,andgavehismindtominuteobservationoftheartofthegreatmastersbywhoseworkshewassurrounded。HespenttwomonthsinFlorence,sixweeksinVenice,afewdaysinBolognaandParma。\"If,\"hesaid,\"IhadneverseenanyofthefineworksofCorreggio,Ishouldnever,perhaps,haveremarkedinNaturetheexpressionwhichIfindinoneofhispieces;orifIhadremarkedit,Imighthavethoughtittoodifficult,orperhapsimpossibletoexecute。\" In1753ReynoldscamebacktoEngland,andstayedthreemonthsinDevonshirebeforesettingupastudioinLondon,inSt。Martin’sLane,whichwasthenanartists’quarter。Hissuccesswasrapid。 In1755hehadonehundredandtwenty-fivesitters。SamuelJohnsonfoundinhimhismostcongenialfriend。HemovedtoNewportStreet,andhebuilthimselfastudio——wherethereisnowanauctionroom——at47,Lincoln’sInnFields。Thereheremainedforlife。 In1760theartistsopened,inaroomlentbytheSocietyofArts,afreeExhibitionforthesaleoftheirworks。ThiswascontinuedthenextyearatSpringGardens,withachargeofashillingforadmission。In1765theyobtainedacharterofincorporation,andin1768theKinggavehissupporttothefoundationofaRoyalAcademyofArtsbysecedersfromthepreceding\"IncorporatedSocietyofArtists,\"intowhichpersonalfeelingshadbroughtmuchdivision。Itwastoconsist,liketheFrenchAcademy,offortymembers,andwastomaintainSchoolsopentoallstudentsofgoodcharacterwhocouldgiveevidencethattheyhadfullylearnttherudimentsofArt。ThefoundationbytheKingdatesfromthe10thofDecember,1768。TheSchoolswereopenedonthe2ndofJanuarynextfollowing,andonthatoccasionJoshuaReynolds,whohadbeenelectedPresident——hisagewasthenbetweenforty-fiveandforty- six——gavetheInauguralAddresswhichformedthefirstoftheseSevenDiscourses。Theothersixweregivenbyhim,asPresident,atthenextsixannualmeetings:andtheywereallshapedtoform,whencollectedintoavolume,acoherentbodyofgoodcounseluponthefoundationsofthepainter’sart。 H。M。 TOTHEKING Theregularprogressofcultivatedlifeisfromnecessariestoaccommodations,fromaccommodationstoornaments。Byyourillustriouspredecessorswereestablishedmartsformanufactures,andcollegesforscience;butfortheartsofelegance,thoseartsbywhichmanufacturesareembellishedandscienceisrefined,tofoundanacademywasreservedforyourMajesty。 Hadsuchpatronagebeenwithouteffect,therehadbeenreasontobelievethatnaturehad,bysomeinsurmountableimpediment,obstructedourproficiency;buttheannualimprovementoftheexhibitionswhichyourMajestyhasbeenpleasedtoencourageshowsthatonlyencouragementhadbeenwanting。 TogiveadvicetothosewhoarecontendingforroyalliberalityhasbeenforsomeyearsthedutyofmystationintheAcademy;andtheseDiscourseshopeforyourMajesty’sacceptanceaswell- intendedendeavourstoincitethatemulationwhichyournoticehaskindled,anddirectthosestudieswhichyourbountyhasrewarded。 MayitpleaseyourMajesty,YourMajesty’sMostdutifulservant,Andmostfaithfulsubject,JOSHUAREYNOLDS。 TOTHEMEMBERSOFTHEROYALACADEMY。 Gentlemen,——ThatyouhaveorderedthepublicationofthisDiscourseisnotonlyveryflatteringtome,asitimpliesyourapprobationofthemethodofstudywhichIhaverecommended;butlikewise,asthismethodreceivesfromthatactsuchanadditionalweightandauthorityasdemandsfromthestudentsthatdeferenceandrespect,whichcanbedueonlytotheunitedsenseofsoconsiderableabodyofartists。 Iam,Withthegreatestesteemandrespect,GENTLEMEN,YourmosthumbleAndobedientservant,JOSHUAREYNOLDS SEVENDISCOURSESONART ADISCOURSE DeliveredattheOpeningoftheRoyalAcademy,January2nd,1769,bythePresidentGentlemen,——Anacademyinwhichthepoliteartsmayberegularlycultivatedisatlastopenedamongusbyroyalmunificence。Thismustappearaneventinthehighestdegreeinteresting,notonlytotheartists,buttothewholenation。 ItisindeeddifficulttogiveanyotherreasonwhyanEmpirelikethatofBritainshouldsolonghavewantedanornamentsosuitabletoitsgreatnessthanthatslowprogressionofthingswhichnaturallymakeseleganceandrefinementthelasteffectofopulenceandpower。 Aninstitutionlikethishasoftenbeenrecommendeduponconsiderationsmerelymercantile。Butanacademyfoundeduponsuchprinciplescannevereffectevenitsownnarrowpurposes。Ifithasanoriginnohigher,notastecaneverbeformedinitwhichcanbeusefuleveninmanufactures;butifthehigherartsofdesignflourish,theseinferiorendswillbeansweredofcourse。 Wearehappyinhavingaprincewhohasconceivedthedesignofsuchaninstitution,accordingtoitstruedignity,andpromotesthearts,astheheadofagreat,alearned,apolite,andacommercialnation;andIcannowcongratulateyou,gentlemen,ontheaccomplishmentofyourlongandardentwishes。 ThenumberlessandineffectualconsultationsthatIhavehadwithmanyinthisassembly,toformplansandconcertschemesforanacademy,affordasufficientproofoftheimpossibilityofsucceedingbutbytheinfluenceofMajesty。Buttherehave,perhaps,beentimeswheneventheinfluenceofMajestywouldhavebeenineffectual,anditispleasingtoreflectthatwearethusembodied,wheneverycircumstanceseemstoconcurfromwhichhonourandprosperitycanprobablyarise。 Thereareatthistimeagreaternumberofexcellentartiststhanwereeverknownbeforeatoneperiodinthisnation;thereisageneraldesireamongournobilitytobedistinguishedasloversandjudgesofthearts;thereisagreatersuperfluityofwealthamongthepeopletorewardtheprofessors;and,aboveall,wearepatronisedbyamonarch,who,knowingthevalueofscienceandofelegance,thinkseveryartworthyofhisnoticethattendstosoftenandhumanisethemind。 AftersomuchhasbeendonebyhisMajesty,itwillbewhollyourfaultifourprogressisnotinsomedegreecorrespondenttothewisdomand,generosityoftheinstitution;letusshowourgratitudeinourdiligence,that,thoughourmeritmaynotanswerhisexpectations,yet,atleast,ourindustrymaydeservehisprotection。 Butwhatevermaybeourproportionofsuccess,ofthiswemaybesure,thatthepresentinstitutionwillatleastcontributetoadvanceourknowledgeofthearts,andbringusnearertothatidealexcellencewhichitisthelotofgeniusalwaystocontemplateandnevertoattain。 Theprincipaladvantageofanacademyis,that,besidesfurnishingablementodirectthestudent,itwillbearepositoryforthegreatexamplesoftheart。Thesearethematerialsonwhichgeniusistowork,andwithoutwhichthestrongestintellectmaybefruitlesslyordeviouslyemployed。Bystudyingtheseauthenticmodels,thatideaofexcellencewhichistheresultoftheaccumulatedexperienceofpastagesmaybeatonceacquired,andthetardyandobstructedprogressofourpredecessorsmayteachusashorterandeasierway。Thestudentreceivesatoneglancetheprincipleswhichmanyartistshavespenttheirwholelivesinascertaining;and,satisfiedwiththeireffect,issparedthepainfulinvestigationbywhichtheycometobeknownandfixed。 Howmanymenofgreatnaturalabilitieshavebeenlosttothisnationforwantoftheseadvantages?Theyneverhadanopportunityofseeingthosemasterlyeffortsofgeniuswhichatoncekindlethewholesoul,andforceitintosuddenandirresistibleapprobation。 Raffaelle,itistrue,hadnottheadvantageofstudyinginanacademy;butallRome,andtheworksofMichaelAngeloinparticular,weretohimanacademy。OnthesiteoftheCapellaSistinaheimmediatelyfromadry,Gothic,andeveninsipidmanner,whichattendstotheminuteaccidentaldiscriminationsofparticularandindividualobjects,assumedthatgrandstyleofpainting,whichimprovespartialrepresentationbythegeneralandinvariableideasofnature。 Everyseminaryoflearningmaybesaidtobesurroundedwithanatmosphereoffloatingknowledge,whereeverymindmayimbibesomewhatcongenialtoitsownoriginalconceptions。Knowledge,thusobtained,hasalwayssomethingmorepopularandusefulthanthatwhichisforceduponthemindbyprivatepreceptsorsolitarymeditation。Besides,itisgenerallyfoundthatayouthmoreeasilyreceivesinstructionfromthecompanionsofhisstudies,whosemindsarenearlyonalevelwithhisown,thanfromthosewhoaremuchhissuperiors;anditisfromhisequalsonlythathecatchesthefireofemulation。 Oneadvantage,Iwillventuretoaffirm,weshallhaveinouracademy,whichnoothernationcanboast。Weshallhavenothingtounlearn。Tothispraisethepresentraceofartistshaveajustclaim。Asfarastheyhaveyetproceededtheyareright。Withustheexertionsofgeniuswillhenceforwardbedirectedtotheirproperobjects。Itwillnotbeasithasbeeninotherschools,wherehethattravelledfastestonlywanderedfarthestfromtherightway。 ImpressedasIam,therefore,withsuchafavourableopinionofmyassociatesinthisundertaking,itwouldillbecomemetodictatetoanyofthem。Butastheseinstitutionshavesooftenfailedinothernations,andasitisnaturaltothinkwithregrethowmuchmighthavebeendone,andhowlittlehasbeendone,Imusttakeleavetoofferafewhints,bywhichthoseerrorsmayberectified,andthosedefectssupplied。Thesetheprofessorsandvisitorsmayrejectoradoptastheyshallthinkproper。 Iwouldchieflyrecommendthatanimplicitobediencetotherulesofart,asestablishedbythegreatmasters,shouldbeexactedfromtheYOUNGstudents。Thatthosemodels,whichhavepassedthroughtheapprobationofages,shouldbeconsideredbythemasperfectandinfallibleguidesassubjectsfortheirimitation,nottheircriticism。 Iamconfidentthatthisistheonlyefficaciousmethodofmakingaprogressinthearts;andthathewhosetsoutwithdoubtingwillfindlifefinishedbeforehebecomesmasteroftherudiments。Foritmaybelaiddownasamaxim,thathewhobeginsbypresumingonhisownsensehasendedhisstudiesassoonashehascommencedthem。Everyopportunity,therefore,shouldbetakentodiscountenancethatfalseandvulgaropinionthatrulesarethefettersofgenius。Theyarefettersonlytomenofnogenius;asthatarmour,whichuponthestrongbecomesanornamentandadefence,upontheweakandmisshapenturnsintoaload,andcripplesthebodywhichitwasmadetoprotect。 Howmuchlibertymaybetakentobreakthroughthoserules,and,asthepoetexpressesit,\"Tosnatchagracebeyondthereachofart,\" maybeanafterconsideration,whenthepupilsbecomemastersthemselves。Itisthen,whentheirgeniushasreceiveditsutmostimprovement,thatrulesmaypossiblybedispensedwith。Butletusnotdestroythescaffolduntilwehaveraisedthebuilding。 Thedirectorsoughtmoreparticularlytowatchoverthegeniusofthosestudentswho,beingmoreadvanced,arearrivedatthatcriticalperiodofstudy,onthenicemanagementofwhichtheirfutureturnoftastedepends。Atthatageitisnaturalforthemtobemorecaptivatedwithwhatisbrilliantthanwithwhatissolid,andtoprefersplendidnegligencetopainfulandhumiliatingexactness。 Afacilityincomposing,alively,andwhatiscalledamasterlyhandlingthechalkorpencil,are,itmustbeconfessed,captivatingqualitiestoyoungminds,andbecomeofcoursetheobjectsoftheirambition。Theyendeavourtoimitatethosedazzlingexcellences,whichtheywillfindnogreatlabourinattaining。Aftermuchtimespentinthesefrivolouspursuits,thedifficultywillbetoretreat;butitwillbethentoolate;andthereisscarceaninstanceofreturntoscrupulouslabourafterthemindhasbeendebauchedanddeceivedbythisfallaciousmastery。 Bythisuselessindustrytheyareexcludedfromallpowerofadvancinginrealexcellence。Whilstboys,theyarearrivedattheirutmostperfection;theyhavetakentheshadowforthesubstance;andmakethatmechanicalfacilitythechiefexcellenceoftheart,whichisonlyanornament,andofthemeritofwhichfewbutpaintersthemselvesarejudges。 Thisseemstometobeoneofthemostdangeroussourcesofcorruption;andIspeakofitfromexperience,notasanerrorwhichmaypossiblyhappen,butwhichhasactuallyinfectedallforeignacademies。Thedirectorswereprobablypleasedwiththisprematuredexterityintheirpupils,andpraisedtheirdespatchattheexpenseoftheircorrectness。 Butyoungmenhavenotonlythisfrivolousambitionofbeingthoughtmasterlyincitingthemononehand,butalsotheirnaturalslothtemptingthemontheother。Theyareterrifiedattheprospectbeforethem,ofthetoilrequiredtoattainexactness。 Theimpetuosityofyouthisdistrustedattheslowapproachesofaregularsiege,anddesires,frommereimpatienceoflabour,totakethecitadelbystorm。Theywishtofindsomeshorterpathtoexcellence,andhopetoobtaintherewardofeminencebyothermeansthanthosewhichtheindispensablerulesofarthaveprescribed。Theymust,therefore,betoldagainandagainthatlabouristheonlypriceofsolidfame,andthatwhatevertheirforceofgeniusmaybe,thereisnoeasymethodofbecomingagoodpainter。 Whenwereadthelivesofthemosteminentpainters,everypageinformsusthatnopartoftheirtimewasspentindissipation。 Evenanincreaseoffameservedonlytoaugmenttheirindustry。Tobeconvincedwithwhatperseveringassiduitytheypursuedtheirstudies,weneedonlyreflectontheirmethodofproceedingintheirmostcelebratedworks。Whentheyconceivedasubject,theyfirstmadeavarietyofsketches;thenafinisheddrawingofthewhole;afterthatamorecorrectdrawingofeveryseparatepart,heads,hands,feet,andpiecesofdrapery;theythenpaintedthepicture,andafterallre-toucheditfromthelife。Thepictures,thuswroughtwithsuchpain,nowappearliketheeffectofenchantment,andasifsomemightygeniushadstruckthemoffatablow。 But,whilstdiligenceisthusrecommendedtothestudents,thevisitorswilltakecarethattheirdiligencebeeffectual;thatitbewelldirectedandemployedontheproperobject。Astudentisnotalwaysadvancingbecauseheisemployed;hemustapplyhisstrengthtothatpartoftheartwheretherealdifficultieslie; tothatpartwhichdistinguishesitasaliberalart,andnotbymistakenindustrylosehistimeinthatwhichismerelyornamental。 Thestudents,insteadofvyingwitheachotherwhichshallhavethereadiestband,shouldbetaughttocontendwhoshallhavethepurestandmostcorrectoutline,insteadofstrivingwhichshallproducethebrightesttint,or,curiouslytriflingendeavourtogivetheglossofstuffssoastoappearreal,lettheirambitionbedirectedtocontendwhichshalldisposehisdraperyinthemostgracefulfolds,whichshallgivethemostgraceanddignitytothehumanfigure。 Imustbegleavetosubmitonethingmoretotheconsiderationofthevisitors,whichappearstomeamatterofverygreatconsequence,andtheomissionofwhichIthinkaprincipaldefectinthemethodofeducationpursuedinalltheacademiesIhaveevervisited。TheerrorImeanis,thatthestudentsneverdrawexactlyfromthelivingmodelswhichtheyhavebeforethem。Itisnotindeedtheirintention,noraretheydirectedtodoit。Theirdrawingsresemblethemodelonlyintheattitude。Theychangetheformaccordingtotheirvagueanduncertainideasofbeauty,andmakeadrawingratherofwhattheythinkthefigureoughttobethanofwhatitappears。Ihavethoughtthistheobstaclethathasstoppedtheprogressofmanyyoungmenofrealgenius;andIverymuchdoubtwhetherahabitofdrawingcorrectlywhatweseewillnotgiveaproportionablepowerofdrawingcorrectlywhatweimagine。Hewhoendeavourstocopynicelythefigurebeforehimnotonlyacquiresahabitofexactnessandprecision,butiscontinuallyadvancinginhisknowledgeofthehumanfigure;andthoughheseemstosuperficialobserverstomakeaslowerprogress,hewillbefoundatlastcapableofadding(withoutrunningintocapriciouswildness)thatgraceandbeautywhichisnecessarytobegiventohismorefinishedworks,andwhichcannotbegotbythemoderns,asitwasnotacquiredbytheancients,butbyanattentiveandwell-comparedstudyofthehumanform。 WhatIthinkoughttoenforcethismethodis,thatithasbeenthepractice(asmaybeseenbytheirdrawings)ofthegreatmastersintheart。IwillmentionadrawingofRaffaelle,\"TheDisputeoftheSacrament,\"theprintofwhich,byCountCailus,isineveryhand。Itappearsthathemadehissketchfromonemodel;andthehabithehadofdrawingexactlyfromtheformbeforehimappearsbyhismakingallthefigureswiththesamecap,suchashismodelthenhappenedtowear;soservileacopyistwasthisgreatman,evenatatimewhenhewasallowedtobeathishighestpitchofexcellence。 IhaveseenalsoacademyfiguresbyAnnibaleCaracci,thoughhewasoftensufficientlylicentiousinhisfinishedworks,drawnwithallthepeculiaritiesofanindividualmodel。 Thisscrupulousexactnessissocontrarytothepracticeoftheacademies,thatitisnotwithoutgreatdeferencethatIbegleavetorecommendittotheconsiderationofthevisitors,andsubmitittothem,whethertheneglectofthismethodisnotoneofthereasonswhystudentssooftendisappointexpectation,andbeingmorethanboysatsixteen,becomelessthanmenatthirty。 Inshort,themethodIrecommendcanonlybedetrimentalwhentherearebutfewlivingformstocopy;forthenstudents,byalwaysdrawingfromonealone,willbyhabitbetaughttooverlookdefects,andmistakedeformityforbeauty。Butofthisthereisnodanger,sincethecouncilhasdeterminedtosupplytheacademywithavarietyofsubjects;andindeedthoselawswhichtheyhavedrawnup,andwhichthesecretarywillpresentlyreadforyourconfirmation,haveinsomemeasureprecludedmefromsayingmoreuponthisoccasion。Instead,therefore,ofofferingmyadvice,permitmetoindulgemywishes,andexpressmyhope,thatthisinstitutionmayanswertheexpectationsofitsroyalfounder;thatthepresentagemayvieinartswiththatofLeoX。andthat\"thedignityofthedyingart\"(tomakeuseofanexpressionofPliny) mayberevivedunderthereignofGeorgeIII。 ADISCOURSE DeliveredtotheStudentsoftheRoyalAcademy,ontheDistributionofthePrizes,December11,I769,bythePresident。 Gentlemen,——Icongratulateyouonthehonourwhichyouhavejustreceived。Ihavethehighestopinionofyourmerits,andcouldwishtoshowmysenseoftheminsomethingwhichpossiblymaybemoreusefultoyouthanbarrenpraise。Icouldwishtoleadyouintosuchacourseofstudyasmayrenderyourfutureprogressanswerabletoyourpastimprovement;and,whilstIapplaudyouforwhathasbeendone,remindyouofhowmuchyetremainstoattainperfection。 Iflattermyself,thatfromthelongexperienceIhavehad,andtheunceasingassiduitywithwhichIhavepursuedthosestudies,inwhich,likeyou,Ihavebeenengaged,Ishallbeacquittedofvanityinofferingsomehintstoyourconsideration。Theyareindeedinagreatdegreefoundeduponmyownmistakesinthesamepursuit。Butthehistoryoferrorsproperlymanagedoftenshortenstheroadtotruth。AndalthoughnomethodofstudythatIcanofferwillofitselfconducttoexcellence,yetitmaypreserveindustryfrombeingmisapplied。 Inspeakingtoyouofthetheoryoftheart,Ishallonlyconsideritasithasarelationtothemethodofyourstudies。 Dividingthestudyofpaintingintothreedistinctperiods,Ishalladdressyouashavingpassedthroughthefirstofthem,whichisconfinedtotherudiments,includingafacilityofdrawinganyobjectthatpresentsitself,atolerablereadinessinthemanagementofcolours,andanacquaintancewiththemostsimpleandobviousrulesofcomposition。 Thisfirstdegreeofproficiencyis,inpainting,whatgrammarisinliterature,ageneralpreparationtowhateverspeciesoftheartthestudentmayafterwardschooseforhismoreparticularapplication。Thepowerofdrawing,modelling,andusingcoloursisveryproperlycalledthelanguageoftheart;andinthislanguage,thehonoursyouhavejustreceivedproveyoutohavemadenoinconsiderableprogress。 Whentheartistisonceenabledtoexpresshimselfwithsomedegreeofcorrectness,hemustthenendeavourtocollectsubjectsforexpression;toamassastockofideas,tobecombinedandvariedasoccasionmayrequire。Heisnowinthesecondperiodofstudy,inwhichhisbusinessistolearnallthathashithertobeenknownanddone。Havinghithertoreceivedinstructionsfromaparticularmaster,heisnowtoconsidertheartitselfashismaster。Hemustextendhiscapacitytomoresublimeandgeneralinstructions。 Thoseperfectionswhichliescatteredamongvariousmastersarenowunitedinonegeneralidea,whichishenceforthtoregulatehistasteandenlargehisimagination。Withavarietyofmodelsthusbeforehim,hewillavoidthatnarrownessandpovertyofconceptionwhichattendsabigotedadmirationofasinglemaster,andwillceasetofollowanyfavouritewhereheceasestoexcel。Thisperiodis,however,stillatimeofsubjectionanddiscipline。 Thoughthestudentwillnotresignhimselfblindlytoanysingleauthoritywhenhemayhavetheadvantageofconsultingmany,hemuststillbeafraidoftrustinghisownjudgment,andofdeviatingintoanytrackwherehecannotfindthefootstepsofsomeformermaster。 Thethirdandlastperiodemancipatesthestudentfromsubjectiontoanyauthoritybutwhatheshallhimselfjudgetobesupportedbyreason。Confidingnowinhisownjudgment,hewillconsiderandseparatethosedifferentprinciplestowhichdifferentmodesofbeautyowetheiroriginal。Intheformerperiodhesoughtonlytoknowandcombineexcellence,whereveritwastobefound,intooneideaofperfection;inthishelearns,whatrequiresthemostattentivesurveyandthesubtledisquisition,todiscriminateperfectionsthatareincompatiblewitheachother。 Heisfromthistimetoregardhimselfasholdingthesamerankwiththosemasterswhomhebeforeobeyedasteachers,andasexercisingasortofsovereigntyoverthoseruleswhichhavehithertorestrainedhim。Comparingnownolongertheperformancesofartwitheachother,butexaminingtheartitselfbythestandardofnature,hecorrectswhatiserroneous,supplieswhatisscanty,andaddsbyhisownobservationwhattheindustryofhispredecessorsmayhaveyetleftwantingtoperfection。Havingwellestablishedhisjudgment,andstoredhismemory,hemaynowwithoutfeartrythepowerofhisimagination。Themindthathasbeenthusdisciplinedmaybeindulgedinthewarmestenthusiasm,andventuretoplayonthebordersofthewildestextravagance。Thehabitualdignity,whichlongconversewiththegreatestmindshasimpartedtohim,willdisplayitselfinallhisattempts,andhewillstandamonghisinstructors,notasanimitator,butarival。 Thesearethedifferentstagesoftheart。ButasInowaddressmyselfparticularlytothosestudentswhohavebeenthisdayrewardedfortheirhappypassagethroughthefirstperiod,Icanwithnoproprietysupposetheywantanyhelpintheinitiatorystudies。Mypresentdesignistodirectyourviewtodistantexcellence,andtoshowyouthereadiestpaththatleadstoit。OfthisIshallspeakwithsuchlatitudeasmayleavetheprovinceoftheprofessoruninvaded,andshallnotanticipatethosepreceptswhichitishisbusinesstogiveandyourdutytounderstand。 Itisindisputablyevidentthatagreatpartofeveryman’slifemustbeemployedincollectingmaterialsfortheexerciseofgenius。Invention,strictlyspeaking,islittlemorethananewcombinationofthoseimageswhichhavebeenpreviouslygatheredanddepositedinthememory。Nothingcancomeofnothing。Hewhohaslaidupnomaterialscanproducenocombinations。 Astudentunacquaintedwiththeattemptsofformeradventurersisalwaysapttooverratehisownabilities,tomistakethemosttriflingexcursionsfordiscoveriesofmoment,andeverycoastnewtohimforanew-foundcountry。Ifbychancehepassesbeyondhisusuallimits,hecongratulateshisownarrivalatthoseregionswhichtheywhohavesteeredabettercoursehavelongleftbehindthem。 Theproductionsofsuchmindsareseldomdistinguishedbyanairoforiginality:theyareanticipatedintheirhappiestefforts;andiftheyarefoundtodifferinanythingfromtheirpredecessors,itisonlyinirregularsalliesandtriflingconceits。Themoreextensivethereforeyouracquaintanceiswiththeworksofthosewhohaveexcelledthemoreextensivewillbeyourpowersofinvention;andwhatmayappearstillmorelikeaparadox,themoreoriginalwillbeyourconceptions。Butthedifficultyonthisoccasionistodeterminewhooughttobeproposedasmodelsofexcellence,andwhooughttobeconsideredastheproperestguides。 ToayoungmanjustarrivedinItaly,manyofthepresentpaintersofthatcountryarereadyenoughtoobtrudetheirprecepts,andtooffertheirownperformancesasexamplesofthatperfectionwhichtheyaffecttorecommend。Themodern,however,whorecommendsHIMSELFasastandard,mayjustlybesuspectedasignorantofthetrueend,andunacquaintedwiththeproperobjectoftheartwhichheprofesses。Tofollowsuchaguidewillnotonlyretardthestudent,butmisleadhim。 Onwhom,then,canherely,orwhoshallshowhimthepaththatleadstoexcellence?Theanswerisobvious:Thosegreatmasterswhohavetravelledthesameroadwithsuccessarethemostlikelytoconductothers。Theworksofthosewhohavestoodthetestofageshaveaclaimtothatrespectandvenerationtowhichnomoderncanpretend。Thedurationandstabilityoftheirfameissufficienttoevincethatithasnotbeensuspendedupontheslenderthreadoffashionandcaprice,butboundtothehumanheartbyeverytieofsympatheticapprobation。 Thereisnodangerofstudyingtoomuchtheworksofthosegreatmen,buthowtheymaybestudiedtoadvantageisaninquiryofgreatimportance。 Somewhohaveneverraisedtheirmindstotheconsiderationoftherealdignityoftheart,andwhoratetheworksofanartistinproportionastheyexcel,oraredefectiveinthemechanicalparts,lookontheoryassomethingthatmayenablethemtotalkbutnottopaintbetter,andconfiningthemselvesentirelytomechanicalpractice,veryassiduouslytoiloninthedrudgeryofcopying,andthinktheymakearapidprogresswhiletheyfaithfullyexhibittheminutestpartofafavouritepicture。Thisappearstomeaverytedious,andIthinkaveryerroneous,methodofproceeding。Ofeverylargecomposition,evenofthosewhicharemostadmired,agreatpartmaybetrulysaidtobecommon-place。This,thoughittakesupmuchtimeincopying,conduceslittletoimprovement。I considergeneralcopyingasadelusivekindofindustry;thestudentsatisfieshimselfwiththeappearanceofdoingsomething; hefallsintothedangeroushabitofimitatingwithoutselecting,andoflabouringwithoutanydeterminateobject;asitrequiresnoeffortofthemind,hesleepsoverhiswork;andthosepowersofinventionandcompositionwhichoughtparticularlytobecalledoutandputinactionlietorpid,andlosetheirenergyforwantofexercise。 Itisanobservationthatallmusthavemade,howincapablethoseareofproducinganythingoftheirownwhohavespentmuchoftheirtimeinmakingfinishedcopies。 Tosupposethatthecomplicationofpowers,andvarietyofideasnecessarytothatmindwhichaspirestothefirsthonoursilltheartofpainting,canbeobtainedbythefrigidcontemplationofafewsinglemodels,isnolessabsurdthanitwouldbeinhimwhowishestobeapoettoimaginethatbytranslatingatragedyhecanacquiretohimselfsufficientknowledgeoftheappearancesofnature,theoperationsofthepassions,andtheincidentsoflife。 Thegreatuseincopying,ifitbeatalluseful,shouldseemtobeinlearningtocolour;yetevencolouringwillneverbeperfectlyattainedbyservilelycopyingthemouldbeforeyou。Aneyecriticallynicecanonlybeformedbyobservingwell-colouredpictureswithattention:andbycloseinspection,andminuteexaminationyouwilldiscover,atlast,themannerofhandling,theartificesofcontrast,glazing,andotherexpedients,bywhichgoodcolouristshaveraisedthevalueoftheirtints,andbywhichnaturehasbeensohappilyimitated。 Imustinformyou,however,thatoldpicturesdeservedlycelebratedfortheircolouringareoftensochangedbydirtandvarnish,thatweoughtnottowonderiftheydonotappearequaltotheirreputationintheeyesofunexperiencedpainters,oryoungstudents。Anartistwhosejudgmentismaturedbylongobservation,considersratherwhatthepictureoncewas,thanwhatitisatpresent。Hehasacquiredapowerbyhabitofseeingthebrilliancyoftintsthroughthecloudbywhichitisobscured。Anexactimitation,therefore,ofthosepictures,islikelytofillthestudent’smindwithfalseopinions,andtosendhimbackacolouristofhisownformation,withideasequallyremotefromnatureandfromart,fromthegenuinepracticeofthemastersandtherealappearancesofthings。 Followingtheserules,andusingtheseprecautions,whenyouhaveclearlyanddistinctlylearnedinwhatgoodcolouringconsists,youcannotdobetterthanhaverecoursetonatureherself,whoisalwaysathand,andincomparisonofwhosetruesplendourthebestcolouredpicturesarebutfaintandfeeble。 However,asthepracticeofcopyingisnotentirelytobeexcluded,sincethemechanicalpracticeofpaintingislearnedinsomemeasurebyit,letthosechoicepartsonlybeselectedwhichhaverecommendedtheworktonotice。Ifitsexcellenceconsistsinitsgeneraleffect,itwouldbepropertomakeslightsketchesofthemachineryandgeneralmanagementofthepicture。Thosesketchesshouldbekeptalwaysbyyoufortheregulationofyourstyle。 Insteadofcopyingthetouchesofthosegreatmasters,copyonlytheirconceptions。Insteadoftreadingintheirfootsteps,endeavouronlytokeepthesameroad。Labourtoinventontheirgeneralprinciplesandwayofthinking。Possessyourselfwiththeirspirit。ConsiderwithyourselfhowaMichaelAngelooraRaffaellewouldhavetreatedthissubject:andworkyourselfintoabeliefthatyourpictureistobeseenandcriticisedbythemwhencompleted。Evenanattemptofthiskindwillrouseyourpowers。 Butasmereenthusiasmwillcarryyoubutalittleway,letmerecommendapracticethatmaybeequivalent,andwillperhapsmoreefficaciouslycontributetoyouradvancement,thaneventheverbalcorrectionsofthosemastersthemselves,couldtheybeobtained。 WhatIwouldproposeis,thatyoushouldenterintoakindofcompetition,bypaintingasimilarsubject,andmakingacompaniontoanypicturethatyouconsiderasamodel。Afteryouhavefinishedyourwork,placeitnearthemodel,andcomparethemcarefullytogether。Youwillthennotonlysee,butfeelyourowndeficienciesmoresensiblythanbyprecepts,oranyothermeansofinstruction。Thetrueprinciplesofpaintingwillminglewithyourthoughts。Ideasthusfixedbysensibleobjects,willbecertainanddefinitive;andsinkingdeepintothemind,willnotonlybemorejust,butmorelastingthanthosepresentedtoyoubypreceptsonly:whichwill,alwaysbefleeting,variable,andundetermined。 Thismethodofcomparingyourowneffortswiththoseofsomegreatmaster,isindeedasevereandmortifyingtask,towhichnonewillsubmit,butsuchashavegreatviews,withfortitudesufficienttoforegothegratificationsofpresentvanityforfuturehonour。 Whenthestudenthassucceededinsomemeasuretohisownsatisfaction,andhasfelicitatedhimselfonhissuccess,togovoluntarilytoatribunalwhereheknowshisvanitymustbehumbled,andallself-approbationmustvanish,requiresnotonlygreatresolution,butgreathumility。Tohim,however,whohastheAmbitiontobearealmaster,thesolidsatisfactionwhichproceedsfromaconsciousnessofhisadvancement(ofwhichseeinghisownfaultsisthefirststep)willveryabundantlycompensateforthemortificationofpresentdisappointment。Thereis,besides,thisalleviatingcircumstance。Everydiscoveryhemakes,everyacquisitionofknowledgeheattains,seemstoproceedfromhisownsagacity;andthusheacquiresaconfidenceinhimselfsufficienttokeepuptheresolutionofperseverance。 Weallmusthaveexperiencedhowlazily,andconsequentlyhowineffectually,instructionisreceivedwhenforceduponthemindbyothers。Fewhavebeentaughttoanypurposewhohavenotbeentheirownteachers。Wepreferthoseinstructionswhichwehavegivenourselves,fromouraffectiontotheinstructor;andtheyaremoreeffectual,frombeingreceivedintothemindattheverytimewhenitismostopenandeagertoreceivethem。 Withrespecttothepicturesthatyouaretochooseforyourmodels,Icouldwishthatyouwouldtaketheworld’sopinionratherthanyourown。Inotherwords,Iwouldhaveyouchoosethoseofestablishedreputationratherthanfollowyourownfancy。Ifyoushouldnotadmirethematfirst,youwill,byendeavouringtoimitatethem,findthattheworldhasnotbeenmistaken。 Itisnotaneasytasktopointoutthosevariousexcellencesforyourimitationwhichhedistributedamongstthevariousschools。 Anendeavourtodothismayperhapsbethesubjectofsomefuturediscourse。Iwill,therefore,atpresentonlyrecommendamodelforstyleinpainting,whichisabranchoftheartmoreimmediatelynecessarytotheyoungstudent。Styleinpaintingisthesameasinwriting,apowerovermaterials,whetherwordsorcolours,bywhichconceptionsorsentimentsareconveyed。AndinthisLodovicoCarrache(Imeaninhisbestworks)appearstometoapproachthenearesttoperfection。Hisunaffectedbreadthoflightandshadow,thesimplicityofcolouring,whichholdingitsproperrank,doesnotdrawasidetheleastpartoftheattentionfromthesubject,andthesolemneffectofthattwilightwhichseemsdiffusedoverhispictures,appeartometocorrespondwithgraveanddignifiedsubjects,betterthanthemoreartificialbrilliancyofsunshinewhichenlightensthepicturesofTitian。 ThoughTintoretthoughtthatTitian’scolouringwasthemodelofperfection,andwouldcorrespondevenwiththesublimeofMichaelAngelo;andthatifAngelohadcolouredlikeTitian,orTitiandesignedlikeAngelo,theworldwouldoncehavehadaperfectpainter。 Itisourmisfortune,however,thatthoseworksofCarrachewhichI wouldrecommendtothestudentarenotoftenfoundoutofBologna。 The\"St。FrancisinthemidstofhisFriars,\"\"TheTransfiguration,\"\"TheBirthofSt。JohntheBaptist,\"\"TheCallingofSt。Matthew,\"the\"St。Jerome,\"thefrescopaintingsintheZampieriPalace,areallworthytheattentionofthestudent。AndIthinkthosewhotravelwoulddowelltoallotamuchgreaterportionoftheirtimetothatcitythanithasbeenhithertothecustomtobestow。 Inthisart,asinothers,therearemanyteacherswhoprofesstoshowthenearestwaytoexcellence,andmanyexpedientshavebeeninventedbywhichthetoilofstudymightbesaved。Butletnomanbeseducedtoidlenessbyspeciouspromises。Excellenceisnevergrantedtomanbutastherewardoflabour。Itargues,indeed,nosmallstrengthofmindtopersevereinhabitsofindustry,withoutthepleasureofperceivingthoseadvances;which,likethehandofaclock,whilsttheymakehourlyapproachestotheirpoint,yetproceedsoslowlyastoescapeobservation。Afacilityofdrawing,likethatofplayinguponamusicalinstrument,cannotbeacquiredbutbyaninfinitenumberofacts。Ineednot,therefore,enforcebymanywordsthenecessityofcontinualapplication;nortellyouthattheport-crayonoughttobeforeverinyourhands。Variousmethodswilloccurtoyoubywhichthispowermaybeacquired。I wouldparticularlyrecommendthatafteryourreturnfromtheacademy(whereIsupposeyourattendancetobeconstant)youwouldendeavourtodrawthefigurebymemory。Iwillevenventuretoadd,thatbyperseveranceinthiscustom,youwillbecomeabletodrawthehumanfiguretolerablycorrect,withaslittleeffortofthemindastotracewithapenthelettersofthealphabet。 Thatthisfacilityisnotunattainable,somemembersinthisacademygiveasufficientproof。And,beassured,thatifthispowerisnotacquiredwhilstyouareyoung,therewillbenotimeforitafterwards:atleast,theattemptwillbeattendedwithasmuchdifficultyasthoseexperiencewholearntoreadorwriteaftertheyhavearrivedtotheageofmaturity。 ButwhileImentiontheport-crayonasthestudent’sconstantcompanion,hemuststillrememberthatthepencilistheinstrumentbywhichhemusthopetoobtaineminence。What,therefore,Iwishtoimpressuponyouis,thatwheneveranopportunityoffers,youpaintyourstudiesinsteadofdrawingthem。Thiswillgiveyousuchafacilityinusingcolours,thatintimetheywillarrangethemselvesunderthepencil,evenwithouttheattentionofthehandthatconductsit。Ifoneactexcludedtheother,thisadvicecouldnotwithanyproprietybegiven。Butifpaintingcomprisesbothdrawingandcolouringandifbyashortstruggleofresoluteindustrythesameexpeditionisattainableinpaintingasindrawingonpaper,Icannotseewhatobjectioncanjustlybemadetothepractice;orwhythatshouldbedonebyparts,whichmaybedonealtogether。 Ifweturnoureyestotheseveralschoolsofpainting,andconsidertheirrespectiveexcellences,weshallfindthatthosewhoexcelmostincolouringpursuedthismethod。TheVenetianandFlemishschools,whichowemuchoftheirfametocolouring,haveenrichedthecabinetsofthecollectorsofdrawingswithveryfewexamples。ThoseofTitian,PaulVeronese,Tintoret,andtheBassans,areingeneralslightandundetermined。Theirsketchesonpaperareasrudeastheirpicturesareexcellentinregardtoharmonyofcolouring。CorreggioandBaroccihaveleftfew,ifany,finisheddrawingsbehindthem。AndintheFlemishschool,RubensandVandykemadetheirdesignsforthemostparteitherincoloursorinchiaroscuro。ItisascommontofindstudiesoftheVenetianandFlemishpaintersoncanvas,asoftheschoolsofRomeandFlorenceonpaper。Notbutthatmanyfinisheddrawingsaresoldunderthenamesofthosemasters。Those,however,areundoubtedlytheproductionseitherofengraversoroftheirscholarswhocopiedtheirworks。 TheseinstructionsIhaveventuredtoofferfrommyownexperience; butastheydeviatewidelyfromreceivedopinions,Iofferthemwithdiffidence;andwhenbetteraresuggested,shallretractthemwithoutregret。 Thereisoneprecept,however,inwhichIshallonlybeopposedbythevain,theignorant,andtheidle。IamnotafraidthatIshallrepeatittoooften。Youmusthavenodependenceonyourowngenius。Ifyouhavegreattalents,industrywillimprovethem:ifyouhavebutmoderateabilities,industrywillsupplytheirdeficiency。Nothingisdeniedtowell-directedlabour:nothingistobeobtainedwithoutit。Nottoenterintometaphysicaldiscussionsonthenatureoressenceofgenius,Iwillventuretoassert,thatassiduityunabatedbydifficulty,andadispositioneagerlydirectedtotheobjectofitspursuit,willproduceeffectssimilartothosewhichsomecalltheresultofnaturalpowers。 Thoughamancannotatalltimes,andinallplaces,paintordraw,yetthemindcanprepareitselfbylayinginpropermaterials,atalltimes,andinallplaces。BothLivyandPlutarch,indescribingPhilopoemen,oneoftheablestgeneralsofantiquity,havegivenusastrikingpictureofamindalwaysintentonitsprofession,andbyassiduityobtainingthoseexcellenceswhichsomealltheirlivesvainlyexpectfromNature。IshallquotethepassageinLivyatlength,asitrunsparallelwiththepracticeI wouldrecommendtothepainter,sculptor,orarchitect。 \"Philopoemenwasamaneminentforhissagacityandexperienceinchoosingground,andinleadingarmies;towhichheformedhismindbyperpetualmeditation,intimesofpeaceaswellaswar。When,inanyoccasionaljourney,hecametoastraightdifficultpassage,ifhewasalone,heconsideredwithhimself,andifhewasincompanyheaskedhisfriendswhatitwouldbebesttodoifinthisplacetheyhadfoundanenemy,eitherinthefront,orintherear,ontheoneside,orontheother。’Itmighthappen,’sayshe,’thattheenemytobeopposedmightcomeondrawnupinregularlines,orinatumultuousbody,formedonlybythenatureoftheplace。’Hethenconsideredalittlewhatgroundheshouldtake; whatnumberofsoldiersheshoulduse,andwhatarmsheshouldgivethem;whereheshouldlodgehiscarriages,hisbaggage,andthedefencelessfollowersofhiscamp;howmanyguards,andofwhatkind,heshouldsendtodefendthem;andwhetheritwouldbebettertopressforwardalongthepass,orrecoverbyretreathisformerstation:hewouldconsiderlikewisewherehiscampcouldmostcommodiouslybeformed;howmuchgroundheshouldenclosewithinhistrenches;whereheshouldhavetheconvenienceofwater;andwherehemightfindplentyofwoodandforage;andwhenheshouldbreakuphiscamponthefollowingday,throughwhatroadhecouldmostsafelypass,andinwhatformheshoulddisposehistroops。 Withsuchthoughtsanddisquisitionshehadfromhisearlyyearssoexercisedhismind,thatontheseoccasionsnothingcouldhappenwhichhehadnotbeenalreadyaccustomedtoconsider。\" IcannothelpimaginingthatIseeapromisingyoungpainter,equallyvigilant,whetherathome,orabroadinthestreets,orinthefields。Everyobjectthatpresentsitselfistohimalesson。 Heregardsallnaturewithaviewtohisprofession;andcombinesherbeauties,orcorrectsherdefects。Heexaminesthecountenanceofmenundertheinfluenceofpassion;andoftencatchesthemostpleasinghintsfromsubjectsofturbulenceordeformity。Evenbadpicturesthemselvessupplyhimwithusefuldocuments;and,asLeonardodaVincihasobserved,heimprovesuponthefancifulimagesthataresometimesseeninthefire,orareaccidentallysketcheduponadiscolouredwall。 Theartistwhohashismindthusfilledwithideas,andhishandmadeexpertbypractice,workswitheaseandreadiness;whilsthewhowouldhaveyoubelievethatheiswaitingfortheinspirationsofgenius,isinrealityatalosshowtobeam,andisatlastdeliveredofhismonsterswithdifficultyandpain。 Thewell-groundedpainter,onthecontrary,hasonlymaturelytoconsiderhissubject,andallthemechanicalpartsofhisartfollowwithouthisexertion,Consciousofthedifficultyofobtainingwhathepossesseshemakesnopretensionstosecrets,exceptthoseofcloserapplication。Withoutconceivingthesmallestjealousyagainstothers,heiscontentedthatallshallbeasgreatashimselfwhoarewillingtoundergothesamefatigue: andashispre-eminencedependsnotuponatrick,heisfreefromthepainfulsuspicionsofajuggler,wholivesinperpetualfearlesthistrickshouldbediscovered。 ADISCOURSE DeliveredtotheStudentsoftheRoyalAcademyontheDistributionofthePrizes,December,14,1770,bythePresidentGentlemen,——Itisnoteasytospeakwithproprietytosomanystudentsofdifferentagesanddifferentdegreesofadvancement。 Themindrequiresnourishmentadaptedtoitsgrowth;andwhatmayhavepromotedourearlierefforts,might,retardusinournearerapproachestoperfection。 Thefirstendeavoursofayoungpainter,asIhaveremarkedinaformerdiscourse,mustbeemployedintheattainmentofmechanicaldexterity,andconfinedtothemereimitationoftheobjectbeforehim。Thosewhohaveadvancedbeyondtherudiments,may,perhaps,findadvantageinreflectingontheadvicewhichIhavelikewisegiventhem,whenIrecommendedthediligentstudyoftheworksofourgreatpredecessors;butIatthesametimeendeavouredtoguardthemagainstanimplicitsubmissiontotheauthorityofanyonemaster,howeverexcellent;orbyastrictimitationofhismanner,toprecludeourselvesfromtheabundanceandvarietyofnature。I willnowaddthatnatureherselfisnottobetoocloselycopied。 Thereareexcellencesintheartofpainting,beyondwhatiscommonlycalledtheimitationofnature:andtheseexcellencesI wishtopointout。Thestudentswho,havingpassedthroughtheinitiatoryexercises,aremoreadvancedintheart,andwho,sureoftheirhand,haveleisuretoexerttheirunderstanding,mustnowbetoldthatamerecopierofnaturecanneverproduceanythinggreat;canneverraiseandenlargetheconceptions,orwarmtheheartofthespectator。 Thewishofthegenuinepaintermustbemoreextensive:insteadofendeavouringtoamusemankindwiththeminuteneatnessofhisimitations,hemustendeavourtoimprovethembythegrandeurofhisideas;insteadofseekingpraise,bydeceivingthesuperficialsenseofthespectator,hemuststriveforfame,bycaptivatingtheimagination。 Theprinciplenowlaiddown,thattheperfectionofthisartdoesnotconsistinmereimitation,isfarfrombeingneworsingular。 Itis,indeed,supportedbythegeneralopinionoftheenlightenedpartofmankind。Thepoets,orators,andrhetoriciansofantiquity,arecontinuallyenforcingthisposition,thatalltheartsreceivetheirperfectionfromanidealbeauty,superiortowhatistobefoundinindividualnature。Theyareeverreferringtothepracticeofthepaintersandsculptorsoftheirtimes,particularlyPhidias(thefavouriteartistofantiquity),toillustratetheirassertions。Asiftheycouldnotsufficientlyexpresstheiradmirationofhisgeniusbywhattheyknew,theyhaverecoursetopoeticalenthusiasm。Theycallitinspiration;agiftfromheaven。Theartistissupposedtohaveascendedthecelestialregions,tofurnishhismindwiththisperfectideaofbeauty。 \"He,\"saysProclus,\"whotakesforhismodelsuchformsasnatureproduces,andconfineshimselftoanexactimitationofthem,willneverattaintowhatisperfectlybeautiful。Fortheworksofnaturearefullofdisproportion,andfallveryshortofthetruestandardofbeauty。SothatPhidias,whenheformedhisJupiter,didnotcopyanyobjecteverpresentstohissight;butcontemplatedonlythatimagewhichhehadconceivedinhismindfromHomer’sdescription。\"AndthusCicero,speakingofthesamePhidias:\"Neitherdidthisartist,\"sayshe,\"whenhecarvedtheimageofJupiterorMinerva,setbeforehimanyonehumanfigureasapattern,whichhewastocopy;buthavingamoreperfectideaofbeautyfixedinhismind,thishesteadilycontemplated,andtotheimitationofthisallhisskillandlabourweredirected。 Themodernsarenotlessconvincedthantheancientsofthissuperiorpowerexistingintheart;norlessconsciousofitseffects。Everylanguagehasadoptedtermsexpressiveofthisexcellence。TheGustograndeoftheItalians;theBeauidealoftheFrenchandtheGREATSTYLE,GENIUS,andTASTEamongtheEnglish,arebutdifferentappellationsofthesamething。Itisthisintellectualdignity,theysay,thatennoblesthepainter’sart;thatlaysthelinebetweenhimandthemeremechanic;andproducesthosegreateffectsinaninstant,whicheloquenceandpoetry,byslowandrepeatedefforts,arescarcelyabletoattain。 Suchisthewarmthwithwhichboththeancientsandmodernsspeakofthisdivineprincipleoftheart;but,asIhaveformerlyobserved,enthusiasticadmirationseldompromotesknowledge。 Thoughastudentbysuchpraisemayhavehisattentionroused,andadesireexcited,ofrunninginthisgreatcareer,yetitispossiblethatwhathasbeensaidtoexcite,mayonlyservetodeterhim。Heexamineshisownmind,andperceivestherenothingofthatdivineinspirationwithwhichheistoldsomanyothershavebeenfavoured。Henevertravelledtoheaventogathernewideas;andhefindshimselfpossessedofnootherqualificationsthanwhatmerecommonobservationandaplainunderstandingcanconfer。Thushebecomesgloomyamidstthesplendouroffigurativedeclamation,andthinksithopelesstopursueanobjectwhichhesupposesoutofthereachofhumanindustry。 Butonthis,asuponmanyotheroccasions,weoughttodistinguishhowmuchistobegiventoenthusiasm,andhowmuchtoreason。Weoughttoallowfor,andweoughttocommend,thatstrengthofvividexpressionwhichisnecessarytoconvey,initsfullforce,thehighestsenseofthemostcompleteeffectofart;takingcareatthesametimenottoloseintermsofvagueadmirationthatsolidityandtruthofprincipleuponwhichalonewecanreason,andmaybeenabledtopractise。 Itisnoteasytodefineinwhatthisgreatstyleconsists;nortodescribe,bywords,thepropermeansofacquiringit,ifthemindofthestudentshouldbeatallcapableofsuchanacquisition。 Couldweteachtasteorgeniusbyrules,theywouldbenolongertasteandgenius。Butthoughthereneitherare,norcanbe,anypreciseinvariablerulesfortheexerciseortheacquisitionofthosegreatqualities,yetwemayastrulysaythattheyalwaysoperateinproportiontoourattentioninobservingtheworksofnature,toourskillinselecting,andtoourcareindigesting,methodising,andcomparingourobservations。Therearemanybeautiesinourart,thatseem,atfirst,toliewithoutthereachofprecept,andyetmayeasilybereducedtopracticalprinciples。 Experienceisallinall;butitisnoteveryonewhoprofitsbyexperience;andmostpeopleerr,notsomuchfromwantofcapacitytofindtheirobject,asfromnotknowingwhatobjecttopursue。 Thisgreatidealperfectionandbeautyarenottobesoughtintheheavens,butupontheearth。Theyareaboutus,anduponeverysideofus。Butthepowerofdiscoveringwhatisdeformedinnature,orinotherwords,whatisparticularanduncommon,canbeacquiredonlybyexperience;andthewholebeautyandgrandeuroftheartconsists,inmyopinion,inbeingabletogetaboveallsingularforms,localcustoms,particularities,anddetailsofeverykind。 Alltheobjectswhichareexhibitedtoourviewbynature,uponcloseexaminationwillbefoundtohavetheirblemishesanddefects。Themostbeautifulformshavesomethingaboutthemlikeweakness,minuteness,orimperfection。Butitisnoteveryeyethatperceivestheseblemishes。Itmustbeaneyelongusedtothecontemplationandcomparisonoftheseforms;andwhich,byalonghabitofobservingwhatanysetofobjectsofthesamekindhaveincommon,thatalonecanacquirethepowerofdiscerningwhateachwantsinparticular。Thislonglaboriouscomparisonshouldbethefirststudyofthepainterwhoaimsatthegreateststyle。Bythismeans,heacquiresajustideaofbeautifulforms;hecorrectsnaturebyherself,herimperfectstatebyhermoreperfect。Hiseyebeingenabledtodistinguishtheaccidentaldeficiencies,excrescences,anddeformitiesofthingsfromtheirgeneralfigures,hemakesoutanabstractideaoftheirformsmoreperfectthananyoneoriginal;andwhatmayseemaparadox,helearnstodesignnaturallybydrawinghisfiguresunliketoanyoneobject。Thisideaoftheperfectstateofnature,whichtheartistcallstheidealbeauty,isthegreatleadingprinciplebywhichworksofgeniusareconducted。BythisPhidiasacquiredhisfame。Hewroughtuponasoberprinciplewhathassomuchexcitedtheenthusiasmoftheworld;andbythismethodyou,whohavecouragetotreadthesamepath,mayacquireequalreputation。