第38章

类别:其他 作者:Baldwin Thomas字数:4770更新时间:18/12/26 16:28:37
Somethingsareonlyactually,somepotentially,some potentiallyandactually,whattheyare,viz。inonecaseaparticular reality,inanother,characterizedbyaparticularquantity,orthe like。Thereisnomovementapartfromthings;forchangeisalways accordingtothecategoriesofbeing,andthereisnothingcommonto theseandinnoonecategory。Buteachofthecategoriesbelongsto allitssubjectsineitheroftwoways(e。g。’this-ness’-forone kindofitis’positiveform’,andtheotheris’privation’;andas regardsqualityonekindis’white’andtheother’black’,andas regardsquantityonekindis’complete’andtheother’incomplete’, andasregardsspatialmovementoneis’upwards’andtheother ’downwards’,oronethingis’light’andanother’heavy’);sothat thereareasmanykindsofmovementandchangeasofbeing。There beingadistinctionineachclassofthingsbetweenthepotential andthecompletelyreal,Icalltheactualityofthepotentialas such,movement。Thatwhatwesayistrue,isplainfromthe followingfacts。Whenthe’buildable’,insofarasitiswhatwemean by’buildable’,existsactually,itisbeingbuilt,andthisisthe processofbuilding。Similarlywithlearning,healing,walking, leaping,ageing,ripening。Movementtakeswhenthecompletereality itselfexists,andneitherearliernorlater。Thecompletereality, then,ofthatwhichexistspotentially,whenitiscompletelyrealand actual,notquaitself,butquamovable,ismovement。ByquaImean this:bronzeispotentiallyastatue;butyetitisnotthecomplete realityofbronzequabronzethatismovement。Foritisnotthe samethingtobebronzeandtobeacertainpotency。Ifitwere absolutelythesameinitsdefinition,thecompleterealityof bronzewouldhavebeenamovement。Butitisnotthesame。(Thisis evidentinthecaseofcontraries;fortobecapableofbeingwelland tobecapableofbeingillarenotthesame-foriftheywere,being wellandbeingillwouldhavebeenthesame-itisthatwhichunderlies andishealthyordiseased,whetheritismoistureorblood,thatis oneandthesame。)Andsinceitisnot。thesame,ascolourandthe visiblearenotthesame,itisthecompleterealityofthepotential, andaspotential,thatismovement。Thatitisthis,andthatmovement takesplacewhenthecompleterealityitselfexists,andneither earliernorlater,isevident。Foreachthingiscapableofbeing sometimesactual,sometimesnot,e。g。thebuildablequabuildable;and theactualityofthebuildablequabuildableisbuilding。Forthe actualityiseitherthis-theactofbuilding-orthehouse。Butwhen thehouseexists,itisnolongerbuildable;thebuildableiswhat isbeingbuilt。Theactuality,then,mustbetheactofbuilding, andthisisamovement。Andthesameaccountappliestoallother movements。 Thatwhatwehavesaidisrightisevidentfromwhatallothers sayaboutmovement,andfromthefactthatitisnoteasytodefineit otherwise。Forfirstlyonecannotputitinanyclass。Thisisevident fromwhatpeoplesay。Somecallitothernessandinequalityandthe unreal;noneofthese,however,isnecessarilymoved,andfurther, changeisnoteithertotheseorfromtheseanymorethanfromtheir opposites。Thereasonwhypeopleputmovementintheseclassesisthat itisthoughttobesomethingindefinite,andtheprinciplesinoneof thetwo’columnsofcontraries’areindefinitebecausetheyare privative,fornoneofthemiseithera’this’ora’such’orinany oftheothercategories。Andthereasonwhymovementisthoughtto beindefiniteisthatitcannotbeclassedeitherwiththepotency ofthingsorwiththeiractuality;forneitherthatwhichiscapable ofbeingofacertainquantity,northatwhichisactuallyofa certainquantity,isofnecessitymoved,andmovementisthoughttobe anactuality,butincomplete;thereasonisthatthepotential, whoseactualityitis,isincomplete。Andthereforeitishardto graspwhatmovementis;foritmustbeclassedeitherunder privationorunderpotencyorunderabsoluteactuality,but evidentlynoneoftheseispossible。Thereforewhatremainsisthatit mustbewhatwesaid-bothactualityandtheactualitywehave described-whichishardtodetectbutcapableofexisting。 Andevidentlymovementisinthemovable;foritisthecomplete realizationofthisbythatwhichiscapableofcausingmovement。 Andtheactualityofthatwhichiscapableofcausingmovementisno otherthanthatofthemovable。Foritmustbethecompleterealityof both。Forwhileathingiscapableofcausingmovementbecauseit candothis,itisamoverbecauseitisactive;butitisonthe movablethatitiscapableofacting,sothattheactualityofbothis one,justasthereisthesameintervalfromonetotwoasfromtwoto one,andasthesteepascentandthesteepdescentareone,butthe beingofthemisnotone;thecaseofthemoverandthemovedis similar。 Theinfiniteiseitherthatwhichisincapableofbeing traversedbecauseitisnotitsnaturetobetraversed(this correspondstothesenseinwhichthevoiceis’invisible’),orthat whichadmitsonlyofincompletetraverseorscarcelyadmitsof traverse,orthatwhich,thoughitnaturallyadmitsoftraverse,is nottraversedorlimited;further,athingmaybeinfinitein respectofadditionorofsubtraction,orboth。Theinfinitecannotbe aseparate,independentthing。Forifitisneitheraspatial magnitudenoraplurality,butinfinityitselfisitssubstanceand notanaccidentofit,itwillbeindivisible;forthedivisibleis eithermagnitudeorplurality。Butifindivisible,itisnotinfinite, exceptasthevoiceisinvisible;butpeopledonotmeanthis,norare weexaminingthissortofinfinite,buttheinfiniteasuntraversable。 Further,howcananinfiniteexistbyitself,unlessnumberand magnitudealsoexistbythemselvess-sinceinfinityisanattribute ofthese?Further,iftheinfiniteisanaccidentofsomethingelse, itcannotbequainfiniteanelementinthings,astheinvisibleis notanelementinspeech,thoughthevoiceisinvisible。Andevidently theinfinitecannotexistactually。Forthenanypartofitthatmight betakenwouldbeinfinite(for’tobeinfinite’and’theinfinite’ arethesame,iftheinfiniteissubstanceandnotpredicatedofa subject)。Thereforeitiseitherindivisible,orifitispartible,it isdivisibleintoinfinites;butthesamethingcannotbemany infinites(asapartofairisair,soapartoftheinfinitewouldbe infinite,iftheinfiniteissubstanceandaprinciple)。Therefore itmustbeimpartibleandindivisible。Buttheactuallyinfinite cannotbeindivisible;foritmustbeofacertainquantity。Therefore infinitybelongstoitssubjectincidentally。Butifso,then(aswe havesaid)itcannotbeitthatisaprinciple,butthatofwhichit isanaccident-theairortheevennumber。 Thisinquiryisuniversal;butthattheinfiniteisnotamong sensiblethings,isevidentfromthefollowingargument。Ifthe definitionofabodyis’thatwhichisboundedbyplanes’,there cannotbeaninfinitebodyeithersensibleorintelligible;nora separateandinfinitenumber,fornumberorthatwhichhasanumberis numerable。Concretely,thetruthisevidentfromthefollowing argument。Theinfinitecanneitherbecompositenorsimple。For(a)it cannotbeacompositebody,sincetheelementsarelimitedin multitude。Forthecontrariesmustbeequalandnooneofthemmustbe infinite;forifoneofthetwobodiesfallsatallshortoftheother inpotency,thefinitewillbedestroyedbytheinfinite。Andthat eachshouldbeinfiniteisimpossible。Forbodyisthatwhichhas extensioninalldirections,andtheinfiniteistheboundlessly extended,sothatiftheinfiniteisabodyitwillbeinfinitein everydirection。Nor(b)cantheinfinitebodybeoneand simple-neither,assomesay,somethingapartfromtheelements,from whichtheygeneratethese(forthereisnosuchbodyapartfromthe elements;foreverythingcanberesolvedintothatofwhichit consists,butnosuchproductofanalysisisobservedexceptthe simplebodies),norfirenoranyotheroftheelements。Forapartfrom thequestionhowanyofthemcouldbeinfinite,theAll,evenifitis finite,cannoteitherbeorbecomeanyoneofthem,asHeraclitussays allthingssometimebecomefire。Thesameargumentappliestothis astotheOnewhichthenaturalphilosopherspositbesidesthe elements。Foreverythingchangesfromcontrarytocontrary,e。g。 fromhottocold。 Further,asensiblebodyissomewhere,andwholeandparthavethe sameproperplace,e。g。thewholeearthandpartoftheearth。 Thereforeif(a)theinfinitebodyishomogeneous,itwillbe unmovableoritwillbealwaysmoving。Butthisisimpossible;forwhy shoulditratherrest,ormove,down,up,oranywhere,ratherthan anywhereelse?E。g。iftherewereaclodwhichwerepartofan infinitebody,wherewillthismoveorrest?Theproperplaceofthe bodywhichishomogeneouswithitisinfinite。Willtheclodoccupy thewholeplace,then?Andhow?(Thisisimpossible。)Whatthenisits restoritsmovement?Itwilleitherresteverywhere,andthenit cannotmove;oritwillmoveeverywhere,andthenitcannotbe still。But(b)iftheAllhasunlikeparts,theproperplacesofthe partsareunlikealso,and,firstly,thebodyoftheAllisnotone exceptbycontact,and,secondly,thepartswillbeeitherfiniteor infiniteinvarietyofkind。Finitetheycannotbe;forthenthose ofonekindwillbeinfiniteinquantityandthoseofanotherwillnot (iftheAllisinfinite),e。g。fireorwaterwouldbeinfinite,but suchaninfiniteelementwouldbedestructiontothecontrary elements。Butifthepartsareinfiniteandsimple,theirplaces alsoareinfiniteandtherewillbeaninfinitenumberofelements; andifthisisimpossible,andtheplacesarefinite,theAllalso mustbelimited。 Ingeneral,therecannotbeaninfinitebodyandalsoaproper placeforbodies,ifeverysensiblebodyhaseitherweightor lightness。Foritmustmoveeithertowardsthemiddleorupwards, andtheinfiniteeitherthewholeorthehalfofit-cannotdo either;forhowwillyoudivideit?Orhowwillpartoftheinfinite bedownandpartup,orpartextremeandpartmiddle?Further,every sensiblebodyisinaplace,andtherearesixkindsofplace,but thesecannotexistinaninfinitebody。Ingeneral,iftherecannotbe aninfiniteplace,therecannotbeaninfinitebody;(andtherecannot beaninfiniteplace,)forthatwhichisinaplaceissomewhere, andthismeanseitherupordownorinoneoftheotherdirections, andeachoftheseisalimit。 Theinfiniteisnotthesameinthesensethatitisasingle thingwhetherexhibitedindistanceorinmovementorintime,butthe posterioramongtheseiscalledinfiniteinvirtueofitsrelation totheprior;i。e。amovementiscalledinfiniteinvirtueofthe distancecoveredbythespatialmovementoralterationorgrowth, andatimeiscalledinfinitebecauseofthemovementwhichoccupies it。