OfIdeasChapterI
OfIdeasingeneral,andtheirOriginal1。Ideaistheobjectofthinking。Everymanbeingconscioustohimselfthathethinks;andthatwhichhismindisappliedaboutwhilstthinkingbeingtheideasthatarethere,itispastdoubtthatmenhaveintheirmindsseveralideas,-suchasarethoseexpressedbythewordswhiteness,hardness,sweetness,thinking,motion,man,elephant,army,drunkenness,andothers:itisinthefirstplacethentobeinquired,Howhecomesbythem?
Iknowitisareceiveddoctrine,thatmenhavenativeideas,andoriginalcharacters,stampedupontheirmindsintheirveryfirstbeing。ThisopinionIhaveatlargeexaminedalready;and,IsupposewhatIhavesaidintheforegoingBookwillbemuchmoreeasilyadmitted,whenIhaveshownwhencetheunderstandingmaygetalltheideasithas;andbywhatwaysanddegreestheymaycomeintothemind;-forwhichIshallappealtoeveryone’sownobservationandexperience。
2。Allideascomefromsensationorreflection。Letusthensupposethemindtobe,aswesay,whitepaper,voidofallcharacters,withoutanyideas:-Howcomesittobefurnished?Whencecomesitbythatvaststorewhichthebusyandboundlessfancyofmanhaspaintedonitwithanalmostendlessvariety?Whencehasitallthematerialsofreasonandknowledge?TothisIanswer,inoneword,fromEXPERIENCE。Inthatallourknowledgeisfounded;andfromthatitultimatelyderivesitself。Ourobservationemployedeither,aboutexternalsensibleobjects,orabouttheinternaloperationsofourmindsperceivedandreflectedonbyourselves,isthatwhichsuppliesourunderstandingswithallthematerialsofthinking。Thesetwoarethefountainsofknowledge,fromwhencealltheideaswehave,orcannaturallyhave,dospring。
3。Theobjectsofsensationonesourceofideas。First,ourSenses,conversantaboutparticularsensibleobjects,doconveyintothemindseveraldistinctperceptionsofthings,accordingtothosevariouswayswhereinthoseobjectsdoaffectthem。Andthuswecomebythoseideaswehaveofyellow,white,heat,cold,soft,hard,bitter,sweet,andallthosewhichwecallsensiblequalities;whichwhenIsaythesensesconveyintothemind,Imean,theyfromexternalobjectsconveyintothemindwhatproducestherethoseperceptions。
Thisgreatsourceofmostoftheideaswehave,dependingwhollyuponoursenses,andderivedbythemtotheunderstanding,IcallSENSATION。
4。Theoperationsofourminds,theothersourceofthem。
Secondly,theotherfountainfromwhichexperiencefurnisheththeunderstandingwithideasis,-theperceptionoftheoperationsofourownmindwithinus,asitisemployedabouttheideasithasgot;-
whichoperations,whenthesoulcomestoreflectonandconsider,dofurnishtheunderstandingwithanothersetofideas,whichcouldnotbehadfromthingswithout。Andsuchareperception,thinking,doubting,believing,reasoning,knowing,willing,andallthedifferentactingsofourownminds;-whichwebeingconsciousof,andobservinginourselves,dofromthesereceiveintoourunderstandingsasdistinctideasaswedofrombodiesaffectingoursenses。Thissourceofideaseverymanhaswhollyinhimself;andthoughitbenotsense,ashavingnothingtodowithexternalobjects,yetitisverylikeit,andmightproperlyenoughbecalledinternalsense。ButasIcalltheotherSENSATION,soICallthisREFLECTION,theideasitaffordsbeingsuchonlyasthemindgetsbyreflectingonitsownoperationswithinitself。Byreflectionthen,inthefollowingpartofthisdiscourse,Iwouldbeunderstoodtomean,thatnoticewhichthemindtakesofitsownoperations,andthemannerofthem,byreasonwhereoftherecometobeideasoftheseoperationsintheunderstanding。Thesetwo,Isay,viz。externalmaterialthings,astheobjectsofSENSATION,andtheoperationsofourownmindswithin,astheobjectsofREFLECTION,aretometheonlyoriginalsfromwhenceallourideastaketheirbeginnings。ThetermoperationshereIuseinalargesense,ascomprehendingnotbarelytheactionsofthemindaboutitsideas,butsomesortofpassionsarisingsometimesfromthem,suchasisthesatisfactionoruneasinessarisingfromanythought。
5。Allourideasareoftheoneortheotherofthese。Theunderstandingseemstomenottohavetheleastglimmeringofanyideaswhichitdothnotreceivefromoneofthesetwo。Externalobjectsfurnishthemindwiththeideasofsensiblequalities,whichareallthosedifferentperceptionstheyproduceinus;andthemindfurnishestheunderstandingwithideasofitsownoperations。
These,whenwehavetakenafullsurveyofthem,andtheirseveralmodes,combinations,andrelations,weshallfindtocontainallourwholestockofideas;andthatwehavenothinginourmindswhichdidnotcomeinoneofthesetwoways。Letanyoneexaminehisownthoughts,andthoroughlysearchintohisunderstanding;andthenlethimtellme,whetheralltheoriginalideashehasthere,areanyotherthanoftheobjectsofhissenses,oroftheoperationsofhismind,consideredasobjectsofhisreflection。Andhowgreatamassofknowledgesoeverheimaginestobelodgedthere,hewill,upontakingastrictview,seethathehasnotanyideainhismindbutwhatoneofthesetwohaveimprinted;-thoughperhaps,withinfinitevarietycompoundedandenlargedbytheunderstanding,asweshallseehereafter。
6。Observableinchildren。Hethatattentivelyconsidersthestateofachild,athisfirstcomingintotheworld,willhavelittlereasontothinkhimstoredwithplentyofideas,thataretobethematterofhisfutureknowledge。Itisbydegreeshecomestobefurnishedwiththem。Andthoughtheideasofobviousandfamiliarqualitiesimprintthemselvesbeforethememorybeginstokeeparegisteroftimeororder,yetitisoftensolatebeforesomeunusualqualitiescomeintheway,thattherearefewmenthatcannotrecollectthebeginningoftheiracquaintancewiththem。Andifitwereworthwhile,nodoubtachildmightbesoorderedastohavebutaveryfew,evenoftheordinaryideas,tillheweregrownuptoaman。Butallthatarebornintotheworld,beingsurroundedwithbodiesthatperpetuallyanddiverselyaffectthem,varietyofideas,whethercarebetakenofitornot,areimprintedonthemindsofchildren。Lightandcoloursarebusyathandeverywhere,whentheeyeisbutopen;soundsandsometangiblequalitiesfailnottosolicittheirpropersenses,andforceanentrancetothemind;-butyet,Ithink,itwillbegrantedeasily,thatifachildwerekeptinaplacewhereheneversawanyotherbutblackandwhitetillhewereaman,hewouldhavenomoreideasofscarletorgreen,thanhethatfromhischildhoodnevertastedanoyster,orapine-apple,hasofthoseparticularrelishes。
7。Menaredifferentlyfurnishedwiththese,accordingtothedifferentobjectstheyconversewith。Menthencometobefurnishedwithfewerormoresimpleideasfromwithout,accordingastheobjectstheyconversewithaffordgreaterorlessvariety;andfromtheoperationsoftheirmindswithin,accordingastheymoreorlessreflectonthem。For,thoughhethatcontemplatestheoperationsofhismind,cannotbuthaveplainandclearideasofthem;yet,unlessheturnhisthoughtsthatway,andconsidersthemattentively,hewillnomorehaveclearanddistinctideasofalltheoperationsofhismind,andallthatmaybeobservedtherein,thanhewillhavealltheparticularideasofanylandscape,orofthepartsandmotionsofaclock,whowillnotturnhiseyestoit,andwithattentionheedallthepartsofit。Thepicture,orclockmaybesoplaced,thattheymaycomeinhiswayeveryday;butyethewillhavebutaconfusedideaofallthepartstheyaremadeupof,tillheapplieshimselfwithattention,toconsiderthemeachinparticular。
8。Ideasofreflectionlater,becausetheyneedattention。Andhenceweseethereasonwhyitisprettylatebeforemostchildrengetideasoftheoperationsoftheirownminds;andsomehavenotanyveryclearorperfectideasofthegreatestpartofthemalltheirlives。
Because,thoughtheypasstherecontinually,yet,likefloatingvisions,theymakenotdeepimpressionsenoughtoleaveintheirmindclear,distinct,lastingideas,tilltheunderstandingturnsinwarduponitself,reflectsonitsownoperations,andmakesthemtheobjectsofitsowncontemplation。Childrenwhentheycomefirstintoit,aresurroundedwithaworldofnewthings,which,byaconstantsolicitationoftheirsenses,drawthemindconstantlytothem;
forwardtotakenoticeofnew,andapttobedelightedwiththevarietyofchangingobjects。Thusthefirstyearsareusuallyemployedanddivertedinlookingabroad。Men’sbusinessinthemistoacquaintthemselveswithwhatistobefoundwithout;andsogrowingupinaconstantattentiontooutwardsensations,seldommakeanyconsiderablereflectiononwhatpasseswithinthem,tilltheycometobeofriperyears;andsomescarceeveratall。
9。Thesoulbeginstohaveideaswhenitbeginstoperceive。Toask,atwhattimeamanhasfirstanyideas,istoask,whenhebeginstoperceive;-havingideas,andperception,beingthesamething。I
knowitisanopinion,thatthesoulalwaysthinks,andthatithastheactualperceptionofideasinitselfconstantly,aslongasitexists;andthatactualthinkingisasinseparablefromthesoulasactualextensionisfromthebody;whichiftrue,toinquireafterthebeginningofaman’sideasisthesameastoinquireafterthebeginningofhissoul。For,bythisaccount,soulanditsideas,asbodyanditsextension,willbegintoexistbothatthesametime。
10。Thesoulthinksnotalways;forthiswantsproofs。Butwhetherthesoulbesupposedtoexistantecedentto,orcoevalwith,orsometimeafterthefirstrudimentsoforganization,orthebeginningsoflifeinthebody,Ileavetobedisputedbythosewhohavebetterthoughtofthatmatter。Iconfessmyselftohaveoneofthosedullsouls,thatdothnotperceiveitselfalwaystocontemplateideas;
norcanconceiveitanymorenecessaryforthesoulalwaystothink,thanforthebodyalwaystomove:theperceptionofideasbeing(asIconceive)tothesoul,whatmotionistothebody;notitsessence,butoneofitsoperations。Andtherefore,thoughthinkingbesupposedneversomuchtheproperactionofthesoul,yetitisnotnecessarytosupposethatitshouldbealwaysthinking,alwaysinaction。That,perhaps,istheprivilegeoftheinfiniteAuthorandPreserverofallthings,who\"neverslumbersnorsleeps;\"butisnotcompetenttoanyfinitebeing,atleastnottothesoulofman。Weknowcertainly,byexperience,thatwesometimesthink;andthencedrawthisinfallibleconsequence,-thatthereissomethinginusthathasapowertothink。Butwhetherthatsubstanceperpetuallythinksorno,wecanbenofurtherassuredthanexperienceinformsus。
For,tosaythatactualthinkingisessentialtothesoul,andinseparablefromit,istobegwhatisinquestion,andnottoproveitbyreason;-whichisnecessarytobedone,ifitbenotaself-evidentproposition。Butwhetherthis,\"Thatthesoulalwaysthinks,\"beaself-evidentproposition,thateverybodyassentstoatfirsthearing,Iappealtomankind。ItisdoubtedwhetherIthoughtatalllastnightorno。Thequestionbeingaboutamatteroffact,itisbeggingittobring,asaproofforit,anhypothesis,whichistheverythingindispute:bywhichwayonemayproveanything,anditisbutsupposingthatallwatches,whilstthebalancebeats,think,anditissufficientlyproved,andpastdoubt,thatmywatchthoughtalllastnight。Buthethatwouldnotdeceivehimself,oughttobuildhishypothesisonmatteroffact,andmakeitoutbysensibleexperience,andnotpresumeonmatteroffact,becauseofhishypothesis,thatis,becausehesupposesittobeso;whichwayofprovingamountstothis,thatImustnecessarilythinkalllastnight,becauseanothersupposesIalwaysthink,thoughImyselfcannotperceivethatIalwaysdoso。
Butmeninlovewiththeiropinionsmaynotonlysupposewhatisinquestion,butallegewrongmatteroffact。Howelsecouldanyonemakeitaninferenceofmine,thatathingisnot,becausewearenotsensibleofitinoursleep?Idonotsaythereisnosoulinaman,becauseheisnotsensibleofitinhissleep;butIdosay,hecannotthinkatanytime,wakingorsleeping:withoutbeingsensibleofit。Ourbeingsensibleofitisnotnecessarytoanythingbuttoourthoughts;andtothemitis;andtothemitalwayswillbenecessary,tillwecanthinkwithoutbeingconsciousofit。
11。Itisnotalwaysconsciousofit。Igrantthatthesoul,inawakingman,isneverwithoutthought,becauseitistheconditionofbeingawake。Butwhethersleepingwithoutdreamingbenotanaffectionofthewholeman,mindaswellasbody,maybeworthawakingman’sconsideration;itbeinghardtoconceivethatanythingshouldthinkandnotbeconsciousofit。Ifthesouldoththinkinasleepingmanwithoutbeingconsciousofit,Iaskwhether,duringsuchthinking,ithasanypleasureorpain,orbecapableofhappinessormisery?Iamsurethemanisnot;nomorethanthebedorearthhelieson。Fortobehappyormiserablewithoutbeingconsciousofit,seemstomeutterlyinconsistentandimpossible。Orifitbepossiblethatthesoulcan,whilstthebodyissleeping,haveitsthinking,enjoyments,andconcerns,itspleasuresorpain,apart,whichthemanisnotconsciousofnorpartakesin,-itiscertainthatSocratesasleepandSocratesawakeisnotthesameperson;buthissoulwhenhesleeps,andSocratestheman,consistingofbodyandsoul,whenheiswaking,aretwopersons:sincewakingSocrateshasnoknowledgeof,orconcernmentforthathappinessormiseryofhissoul,whichitenjoysalonebyitselfwhilsthesleeps,withoutperceivinganythingofit;nomorethanhehasforthehappinessormiseryofamanintheIndies,whomheknowsnot。For,ifwetakewhollyawayallconsciousnessofouractionsandsensations,especiallyofpleasureandpain,andtheconcernmentthataccompaniesit,itwillbehardtoknowwhereintoplacepersonalidentity。
12。Ifasleepingmanthinkswithoutknowingit,thesleepingandwakingmanaretwopersons。Thesoul,duringsoundsleep,thinks,saythesemen。Whilstitthinksandperceives,itiscapablecertainlyofthoseofdelightortrouble,aswellasanyotherperceptions;
anditmustnecessarilybeconsciousofitsownperceptions。Butithasallthisapart:thesleepingman,itisplain,isconsciousofnothingofallthis。Letussuppose,then,thesoulofCastor,whileheissleeping,retiredfromhisbody;whichisnoimpossiblesuppositionforthemenIhaveheretodowith,whosoliberallyallowlife,withoutathinkingsoul,toallotheranimals。Thesemencannotthenjudgeitimpossible,oracontradiction,thatthebodyshouldlivewithoutthesoul;northatthesoulshouldsubsistandthink,orhaveperception,evenperceptionofhappinessormisery,withoutthebody。Letusthen,Isay,supposethesoulofCastorseparatedduringhissleepfromhisbody,tothinkapart。Letussuppose,too,thatitchoosesforitssceneofthinkingthebodyofanotherman,v。g。Pollux,whoissleepingwithoutasoul。For,ifCastor’ssoulcanthink,whilstCastorisasleep,whatCastorisneverconsciousof,itisnomatterwhatplaceitchoosestothinkin。Wehavehere,then,thebodiesoftwomenwithonlyonesoulbetweenthem,whichwewillsupposetosleepandwakebyturns;andthesoulstillthinkinginthewakingman,whereofthesleepingmanisneverconscious,hasnevertheleastperception。Iask,then,whetherCastorandPollux,thuswithonlyonesoulbetweenthem,whichthinksandperceivesinonewhattheotherisneverconsciousof,norisconcernedfor,arenottwoasdistinctpersonsasCastorandHercules,orasSocratesandPlatowere?Andwhetheroneofthemmightnotbeveryhappy,andtheotherverymiserable?Justbythesamereason,theymakethesoulandthemantwopersons,whomakethesoulthinkapartwhatthemanisnotconsciousof。For,Isupposenobodywillmakeidentityofpersonstoconsistinthesoul’sbeingunitedtotheverysamenumercialparticlesofmatter。Forifthatbenecessarytoidentity,itwillbeimpossible,inthatconstantfluxoftheparticlesofourbodies,thatanymanshouldbethesamepersontwodays,ortwomoments,together。
13。Impossibletoconvincethosethatsleepwithoutdreaming,thattheythink。Thus,methinks,everydrowsynodshakestheirdoctrine,whoteachthatthesoulisalwaysthinking。Those,atleast,whodoatanytimesleepwithoutdreaming,canneverbeconvincedthattheirthoughtsaresometimesforfourhoursbusywithouttheirknowingofit;andiftheyaretakenintheveryact,wakedinthemiddleofthatsleepingcontemplation,cangivenomannerofaccountofit。
14。Thatmendreamwithoutrememberingit,invainurged。Itwillperhapsbesaid,-Thatthesoulthinkseveninthesoundestsleep,butthememoryretainsitnot。Thatthesoulinasleepingmanshouldbethismomentbusyathinking,andthenextmomentinawakingmannotremembernorbeabletorecollectonejotofallthosethoughts,isveryhardtobeconceived,andwouldneedsomebetterproofthanbareassertiontomakeitbebelieved。Forwhocanwithoutanymoreado,butbeingbarelytoldso,imaginethatthegreatestpartofmendo,duringalltheirlives,forseveralhourseveryday,thinkofsomething,whichiftheywereasked,eveninthemiddleofthesethoughts,theycouldremembernothingatallof?Mostmen,Ithink,passagreatpartoftheirsleepwithoutdreaming。Ionceknewamanthatwasbredascholar,andhadnobadmemory,whotoldmehehadneverdreamedinhislife,tillhehadthatfeverhewasthennewlyrecoveredof,whichwasaboutthefiveorsixandtwentiethyearofhisage。Isupposetheworldaffordsmoresuchinstances:atleasteveryone’sacquaintancewillfurnishhimwithexamplesenoughofsuchaspassmostoftheirnightswithoutdreaming。
15。Uponthishypothesis,thethoughtsofasleepingmanoughttobemostrational。Tothinkoften,andnevertoretainitsomuchasonemoment,isaveryuselesssortofthinking;andthesoul,insuchastateofthinking,doesverylittle,ifatall,excelthatofalooking-glass,whichconstantlyreceivesvarietyofimages,orideas,butretainsnone;theydisappearandvanish,andthereremainnofootstepsofthem;thelooking-glassisneverthebetterforsuchideas,northesoulforsuchthoughts。Perhapsitwillbesaid,thatinawakingmanthematerialsofthebodyareemployed,andmadeuseof,inthinking;andthatthememoryofthoughtsisretainedbytheimpressionsthataremadeonthebrain,andthetracesthereleftaftersuchthinking;butthatinthethinkingofthesoul,whichisnotperceivedinasleepingman,therethesoulthinksapart,andmakingnouseoftheorgansofthebody,leavesnoimpressionsonit,andconsequentlynomemoryofsuchthoughts。Nottomentionagaintheabsurdityoftwodistinctpersons,whichfollowsfromthissupposition,Ianswer,further,-Thatwhateverideasthemindcanreceiveandcontemplatewithoutthehelpofthebody,itisreasonabletoconcludeitcanretainwithoutthehelpofthebodytoo;orelsethesoul,oranyseparatespirit,willhavebutlittleadvantagebythinking。Ifithasnomemoryofitsownthoughts;ifitcannotlaythemupforitsownuse,andbeabletorecallthemuponoccasion;
ifitcannotreflectuponwhatispast,andmakeuseofitsformerexperiences,reasonings,andcontemplations,towhatpurposedoesitthink?Theywhomakethesoulathinkingthing,atthisrate,willnotmakeitamuchmorenoblebeingthanthosedowhomtheycondemn,forallowingittobenothingbutthesubtilistpartsofmatter。
Charactersdrawnondust,thatthefirstbreathofwindeffaces;orimpressionsmadeonaheapofatoms,oranimalspirits,arealtogetherasuseful,andrenderthesubjectasnoble,asthethoughtsofasoulthatperishinthinking;that,onceoutofsight,aregoneforever,andleavenomemoryofthemselvesbehindthem。Naturenevermakesexcellentthingsformeanornouses:anditishardlytobeconceivedthatourinfinitelywiseCreatorshouldmakesoadmirableafacultywhichcomesnearesttheexcellencyofhisownincomprehensiblebeing,tobesoidlyanduselesslyemployed,atleastafourthpartofitstimehere,astothinkconstantly,withoutrememberinganyofthosethoughts,withoutdoinganygoodtoitselforothers,orbeinganywayusefultoanyotherpartofthecreation,Ifwewillexamineit,weshallnotfind,Isuppose,themotionofdullandsenselessmatter,anywhereintheuniverse,madesolittleuseofandsowhollythrownaway。
16。Onthishypothesis,thesoulmusthaveideasnotderivedfromsensationorreflection,ofwhichthereisnoappearance。Itistrue,wehavesometimesinstancesofperceptionwhilstweareasleep,andretainthememoryofthosethoughts:buthowextravagantandincoherentforthemostparttheyare;howlittleconformabletotheperfectionandorderofarationalbeing,thosewhoareacquaintedwithdreamsneednotbetold。ThisIwouldwillinglybesatisfiedin,-
whetherthesoul,whenitthinksthusapart,andasitwereseparatefromthebody,actslessrationallythanwhenconjointlywithit,orno。Ifitsseparatethoughtsbelessrational,thenthesemenmustsay,thatthesoulowestheperfectionofrationalthinkingtothebody:ifitdoesnot,itisawonderthatourdreamsshouldbe,forthemostpart,sofrivolousandirrational;andthatthesoulshouldretainnoneofitsmorerationalsoliloquiesandmeditations。
17。IfIthinkwhenIknowitnot,nobodyelsecanknowit。Thosewhosoconfidentlytellusthatthesoulalwaysactuallythinks,I
wouldtheywouldalsotellus,whatthoseideasarethatareinthesoulofachild,beforeorjustattheunionwiththebody,beforeithathreceivedanybysensation。Thedreamsofsleepingmenare,asItakeit,allmadeupofthewakingman’sideas;thoughforthemostpartoddlyputtogether。Itisstrange,ifthesoulhasideasofitsownthatitderivednotfromsensationorreflection,(asitmusthave,ifitthoughtbeforeitreceivedanyimpressionsfromthebody,)thatitshouldnever,initsprivatethinking,(soprivate,thatthemanhimselfperceivesitnot,)retainanyofthemtheverymomentitwakesoutofthem,andthenmakethemangladwithnewdiscoveries。Whocanfinditreasonthatthesoulshould,initsretirementduringsleep,havesomanyhours’thoughts,andyetneverlightonanyofthoseideasitborrowednotfromsensationorreflection;oratleastpreservethememoryofnonebutsuch,which,beingoccasionedfromthebody,mustneedsbelessnaturaltoaspirit?Itisstrangethesoulshouldneveronceinaman’swholeliferecalloveranyofitspurenativethoughts,andthoseideasithadbeforeitborrowedanythingfromthebody;neverbringintothewakingman’sviewanyotherideasbutwhathaveatangofthecask,andmanifestlyderivetheiroriginalfromthatunion。Ifitalwaysthinks,andsohadideasbeforeitwasunited,orbeforeitreceivedanyfromthebody,itisnottobesupposedbutthatduringsleepitrecollectsitsnativeideas;andduringthatretirementfromcommunicatingwiththebody,whilstitthinksbyitself,theideasitisbusiedaboutshouldbe,sometimesatleast,thosemorenaturalandcongenialoneswhichithadinitself,underivedfromthebody,oritsownoperationsaboutthem:which,sincethewakingmanneverremembers,wemustfromthishypothesisconcludeeitherthatthesoulrememberssomethingthatthemandoesnot;orelsethatmemorybelongsonlytosuchideasasarederivedfromthebody,orthemind’soperationsaboutthem。
18。Howknowsanyonethatthesoulalwaysthinks?Forifitbenotaself-evidentproposition,itneedsproof。Iwouldbegladalsotolearnfromthesemenwhosoconfidentlypronouncethatthehumansoul,or,whichisallone,thatamanalwaysthinks,howtheycometoknowit;nay,howtheycometoknowthattheythemselvesthinkwhentheythemselvesdonotperceiveit。This,Iamafraid,istobesurewithoutproofs,andtoknowwithoutperceiving。Itis,Isuspect,aconfusednotion,takenuptoserveanhypothesis;andnoneofthosecleartruths,thateithertheirownevidenceforcesustoadmit,orcommonexperiencemakesitimpudencetodeny。Forthemostthatcanbesaidofitis,thatitispossiblethesoulmayalwaysthink,butnotalwaysretainitinmemory。AndIsay,itisaspossiblethatthesoulmaynotalwaysthink;andmuchmoreprobablethatitshouldsometimesnotthink,thanthatitshouldoftenthink,andthatalongwhiletogether,andnotbeconscioustoitself,thenextmomentafter,thatithadthought。
19。\"Thatamanshouldbebusyinthinking,andyetnotretainitthenextmoment,\"veryimprobable。Tosupposethesoultothink,andthemannottoperceiveit,is,ashasbeensaid,tomaketwopersonsinoneman。Andifoneconsiderswellthesemen’swayofspeaking,oneshouldbeledintoasuspicionthattheydoso。Fortheywhotellusthatthesoulalwaysthinks,donever,thatIremember,saythatamanalwaysthinks。Canthesoulthink,andnottheman?
Oramanthink,andnotbeconsciousofit?This,perhaps,wouldbesuspectedofjargoninothers。Iftheysaythemanthinksalways,butisnotalwaysconsciousofit,theymayaswellsayhisbodyisextendedwithouthavingparts。Foritisaltogetherasintelligibletosaythatabodyisextendedwithoutparts,asthatanythingthinkswithoutbeingconsciousofit,orperceivingthatitdoesso。Theywhotalkthusmay,withasmuchreason,ifitbenecessarytotheirhypothesis,saythatamanisalwayshungry,butthathedoesnotalwaysfeelit;whereashungerconsistsinthatverysensation,asthinkingconsistsinbeingconsciousthatonethinks。Iftheysaythatamanisalwaysconscioustohimselfofthinking,Iask,Howtheyknowit?Consciousnessistheperceptionofwhatpassesinaman’sownmind。CananothermanperceivethatIamconsciousofanything,whenI
perceiveitnotmyself?Noman’sknowledgeherecangobeyondhisexperience。Wakeamanoutofasoundsleep,andaskhimwhathewasthatmomentthinkingof。Ifhehimselfbeconsciousofnothinghethenthoughton,hemustbeanotabledivinerofthoughtsthatcanassurehimthathewasthinking。Mayhenot,withmorereason,assurehimhewasnotasleep?Thisissomethingbeyondphilosophy;anditcannotbelessthanrevelation,thatdiscoverstoanotherthoughtsinmymind,whenIcanfindnonetheremyself,AndtheymustneedshaveapenetratingsightwhocancertainlyseethatIthink,whenI
cannotperceiveitmyself,andwhenIdeclarethatIdonot;andyetcanseethatdogsorelephantsdonotthink,whentheygiveallthedemonstrationofitimaginable,exceptonlytellingusthattheydoso。ThissomemaysuspecttobeastepbeyondtheRosicrucians;itseemingeasiertomakeone’sselfinvisibletoothers,thantomakeanother’sthoughtsvisibletome,whicharenotvisibletohimself。
Butitisbutdefiningthesoultobe\"asubstancethatalwaysthinks,\"andthebusinessisdone。Ifsuchdefinitionbeofanyauthority,Iknownotwhatitcanserveforbuttomakemanymensuspectthattheyhavenosoulsatall;sincetheyfindagoodpartoftheirlivespassawaywithoutthinking。FornodefinitionsthatI
know,nosuppositionsofanysect,areofforceenoughtodestroyconstantexperience;andperhapsitistheaffectationofknowingbeyondwhatweperceive,thatmakessomuchuselessdisputeandnoiseintheworld。
20。Noideasbutfromsensationandreflection,evident,ifweobservechildren。Iseenoreason,therefore,tobelievethatthesoulthinksbeforethesenseshavefurnisheditwithideastothinkon;andasthoseareincreasedandretained,soitcomes,byexercise,toimproveitsfacultyofthinkingintheseveralpartsofit;aswellas,afterwards,bycompoundingthoseideas,andreflectingonitsownoperations,itincreasesitsstock,aswellasfacilityinremembering,imagining,reasoning,andothermodesofthinking。
21。Stateofachildinthemother’swomb。Hethatwillsufferhimselftobeinformedbyobservationandexperience,andnotmakehisownhypothesistheruleofnature,willfindfewsignsofasoulaccustomedtomuchthinkinginanew-bornchild,andmuchfewerofanyreasoningatall。Andyetitishardtoimaginethattherationalsoulshouldthinksomuch,andnotreasonatall。Andhethatwillconsiderthatinfantsnewlycomeintotheworldspendthegreatestpartoftheirtimeinsleep,andareseldomawakebutwheneitherhungercallsfortheteat,orsomepain(themostimportunateofallsensations),orsomeotherviolentimpressiononthebody,forcesthemindtoperceiveandattendtoit;-he,Isay,whoconsidersthis,willperhapsfindreasontoimaginethatafoetusinthemother’swombdiffersnotmuchfromthestateofavegetable,butpassesthegreatestpartofitstimewithoutperceptionorthought;doingverylittlebutsleepinaplacewhereitneedsnotseekforfood,andissurroundedwithliquor,alwaysequallysoft,andnearofthesametemper;wheretheeyeshavenolight,andtheearssoshutuparenotverysusceptibleofsounds;andwherethereislittleornovariety,orchangeofobjects,tomovethesenses。
22。Themindthinksinproportiontothematteritgetsfromexperiencetothinkabout。Followachildfromitsbirth,andobservethealterationsthattimemakes,andyoushallfind,asthemindbythesensescomesmoreandmoretobefurnishedwithideas,itcomestobemoreandmoreawake;thinksmore,themoreithasmattertothinkon。Aftersometimeitbeginstoknowtheobjectswhich,beingmostfamiliarwithit,havemadelastingimpressions。
Thusitcomesbydegreestoknowthepersonsitdailyconverseswith,anddistinguishesthemfromstrangers;whichareinstancesandeffectsofitscomingtoretainanddistinguishtheideasthesensesconveytoit。Andsowemayobservehowthemind,bydegrees,improvesinthese;andadvancestotheexerciseofthoseotherfacultiesofenlarging,compounding,andabstractingitsideas,andofreasoningaboutthem,andreflectinguponallthese;ofwhichIshallhaveoccasiontospeakmorehereafter。
23。Amanbeginstohaveideaswhenhefirsthassensation。Whatsensationis。Ifitshallbedemandedthen,whenamanbeginstohaveanyideas,Ithinkthetrueansweris,-whenhefirsthasanysensation。For,sincethereappearnottobeanyideasinthemindbeforethesenseshaveconveyedanyin,Iconceivethatideasintheunderstandingarecoevalwithsensation;whichissuchanimpressionormotionmadeinsomepartofthebody,asproducessomeperceptionintheunderstanding。Itisabouttheseimpressionsmadeonoursensesbyoutwardobjectsthatthemindseemsfirsttoemployitself,insuchoperationsaswecallperception,remembering,consideration,reasoning,&c。
24。Theoriginalofallourknowledge。Intimethemindcomestoreflectonitsownoperationsabouttheideasgotbysensation,andtherebystoresitselfwithanewsetofideas,whichIcallideasofreflection。Thesearetheimpressionsthataremadeonoursensesbyoutwardobjectsthatareextrinsicaltothemind;anditsownoperations,proceedingfrompowersintrinsicalandpropertoitself,which,whenreflectedonbyitself,becomealsoobjectsofitscontemplation-are,asIhavesaid,theoriginalofallknowledge。
Thusthefirstcapacityofhumanintellectis,-thatthemindisfittedtoreceivetheimpressionsmadeonit;eitherthroughthesensesbyoutwardobjects,orbyitsownoperationswhenitreflectsonthem。Thisisthefirststepamanmakestowardsthediscoveryofanything,andthegroundworkwhereontobuildallthosenotionswhicheverheshallhavenaturallyinthisworld。Allthosesublimethoughtswhichtowerabovetheclouds,andreachashighasheavenitself,taketheirriseandfootinghere:inallthatgreatextentwhereinthemindwanders,inthoseremotespeculationsitmayseemtobeelevatedwith,itstirsnotonejotbeyondthoseideaswhichsenseorreflectionhaveofferedforitscontemplation。
25。Inthereceptionofsimpleideas,theunderstandingisforthemostpartpassive。Inthisparttheunderstandingismerelypassive;
andwhetherornoitwillhavethesebeginnings,andasitwerematerialsofknowledge,isnotinitsownpower。Fortheobjectsofoursensesdo,manyofthem,obtrudetheirparticularideasuponourmindswhetherwewillornot;andtheoperationsofourmindswillnotletusbewithout,atleast,someobscurenotionsofthem。Nomancanbewhollyignorantofwhathedoeswhenhethinks。Thesesimpleideas,whenofferedtothemind,theunderstandingcannomorerefusetohave,noralterwhentheyareimprinted,norblotthemoutandmakenewonesitself,thanamirrorcanrefuse,alter,orobliteratetheimagesorideaswhichtheobjectssetbeforeitdothereinproduce。Asthebodiesthatsurroundusdodiverselyaffectourorgans,themindisforcedtoreceivetheimpressions;andcannotavoidtheperceptionofthoseideasthatareannexedtothem。
ChapterII
OfSimpleIdeas1。Uncompoundedappearances。Thebettertounderstandthenature,manner,andextentofourknowledge,onethingiscarefullytobeobservedconcerningtheideaswehave;andthatis,thatsomeofthemaresimpleandsomecomplex。
Thoughthequalitiesthataffectoursensesare,inthethingsthemselves,sounitedandblended,thatthereisnoseparation,nodistancebetweenthem;yetitisplain,theideastheyproduceinthemindenterbythesensessimpleandunmixed。For,thoughthesightandtouchoftentakeinfromthesameobject,atthesametime,differentideas;-asamanseesatoncemotionandcolour;thehandfeelssoftnessandwarmthinthesamepieceofwax:yetthesimpleideasthusunitedinthesamesubject,areasperfectlydistinctasthosethatcomeinbydifferentsenses。Thecoldnessandhardnesswhichamanfeelsinapieceoficebeingasdistinctideasinthemindasthesmellandwhitenessofalily;orasthetasteofsugar,andsmellofarose。Andthereisnothingcanbeplainertoamanthantheclearanddistinctperceptionhehasofthosesimpleideas;which,beingeachinitselfuncompounded,containsinitnothingbutoneuniformappearance,orconceptioninthemind,andisnotdistinguishableintodifferentideas。
2。Themindcanneithermakenordestroythem。Thesesimpleideas,thematerialsofallourknowledge,aresuggestedandfurnishedtothemindonlybythosetwowaysabovementioned,viz。sensationandreflection。Whentheunderstandingisoncestoredwiththesesimpleideas,ithasthepowertorepeat,compare,andunitethem,eventoanalmostinfinitevariety,andsocanmakeatpleasurenewcomplexideas。Butitisnotinthepowerofthemostexaltedwit,orenlargedunderstanding,byanyquicknessorvarietyofthought,toinventorframeonenewsimpleideainthemind,nottakeninbythewaysbeforementioned:norcananyforceoftheunderstandingdestroythosethatarethere。Thedominionofman,inthislittleworldofhisownunderstandingbeingmuchwhatthesameasitisinthegreatworldofvisiblethings;whereinhispower,howevermanagedbyartandskill,reachesnofartherthantocompoundanddividethematerialsthataremadetohishand;butcandonothingtowardsthemakingtheleastparticleofnewmatter,ordestroyingoneatomofwhatisalreadyinbeing。Thesameinabilitywilleveryonefindinhimself,whoshallgoabouttofashioninhisunderstandingonesimpleidea,notreceivedinbyhissensesfromexternalobjects,orbyreflectionfromtheoperationsofhisownmindaboutthem。Iwouldhaveanyonetrytofancyanytastewhichhadneveraffectedhispalate;orframetheideaofascenthehadneversmelt:andwhenhecandothis,Iwillalsoconcludethatablindmanhathideasofcolours,andadeafmantruedistinctnotionsofsounds。
3。Onlythequalitiesthataffectthesensesareimaginable。Thisisthereasonwhy-thoughwecannotbelieveitimpossibletoGodtomakeacreaturewithotherorgans,andmorewaystoconveyintotheunderstandingthenoticeofcorporealthingsthanthosefive,astheyareusuallycounted,whichhehasgiventoman-yetIthinkitisnotpossibleforanymantoimagineanyotherqualitiesinbodies,howsoeverconstituted,wherebytheycanbetakennoticeof,besidessounds,tastes,smells,visibleandtangiblequalities。Andhadmankindbeenmadebutwithfoursenses,thequalitiesthenwhicharetheobjectsofthefifthsensehadbeenasfarfromournotice,imagination,andconception,asnowanybelongingtoasixth,seventh,oreighthsensecanpossiblybe;-which,whetheryetsomeothercreatures,insomeotherpartsofthisvastandstupendousuniverse,maynothave,willbeagreatpresumptiontodeny。Hethatwillnotsethimselfproudlyatthetopofallthings,butwillconsidertheimmensityofthisfabric,andthegreatvarietythatistobefoundinthislittleandinconsiderablepartofitwhichhehastodowith,maybeapttothinkthat,inothermansionsofit,theremaybeotheranddifferentintelligentbeings,ofwhosefacultieshehasaslittleknowledgeorapprehensionasawormshutupinonedrawerofacabinethathofthesensesorunderstandingofaman;suchvarietyandexcellencybeingsuitabletothewisdomandpoweroftheMaker。
Ihaveherefollowedthecommonopinionofman’shavingbutfivesenses;though,perhaps,theremaybejustlycountedmore;-buteithersuppositionservesequallytomypresentpurpose。
ChapterIII
OfSimpleIdeasofSense1。Divisionofsimpleideas。Thebettertoconceivetheideaswereceivefromsensation,itmaynotbeamissforustoconsiderthem,inreferencetothedifferentwayswherebytheymaketheirapproachestoourminds,andmakethemselvesperceivablebyus。
First,then,Therearesomewhichcomeintoourmindsbyonesenseonly。
Secondly,Thereareothersthatconveythemselvesintothemindbymoresensesthanone。
Thirdly,Othersthatarehadfromreflectiononly。
Fourthly,Therearesomethatmakethemselvesway,andaresuggestedtothemindbyallthewaysofsensationandreflection。
Weshallconsiderthemapartundertheseseveralheads。
Ideasofonesense。Therearesomeideaswhichhaveadmittanceonlythroughonesense,whichispeculiarlyadaptedtoreceivethem。
Thuslightandcolours,aswhite,red,yellow,blue;withtheirseveraldegreesorshadesandmixtures,asgreen,scarlet,purple,sea-green,andtherest,comeinonlybytheeyes。Allkindsofnoises,sounds,andtones,onlybytheears。Theseveraltastesandsmells,bythenoseandpalate。Andiftheseorgans,orthenerveswhicharetheconduitstoconveythemfromwithouttotheiraudienceinthebrain,-themind’spresence-room(asImaysocallit)-areanyofthemsodisorderedasnottoperformtheirfunctions,theyhavenoposterntobeadmittedby;nootherwaytobringthemselvesintoview,andbeperceivedbytheunderstanding。
Themostconsiderableofthosebelongingtothetouch,areheatandcold,andsolidity:alltherest,consistingalmostwhollyinthesensibleconfiguration,assmoothandrough;orelse,moreorlessfirmadhesionoftheparts,ashardandsoft,toughandbrittle,areobviousenough。
2。Fewsimpleideashavenames。Ithinkitwillbeneedlesstoenumeratealltheparticularsimpleideasbelongingtoeachsense。Norindeedisitpossibleifwewould;therebeingagreatmanymoreofthembelongingtomostofthesensesthanwehavenamesfor。Thevarietyofsmells,whichareasmanyalmost,ifnotmore,thanspeciesofbodiesintheworld,domostofthemwantnames。Sweetandstinkingcommonlyserveourturnfortheseideas,whichineffectislittlemorethantocallthempleasingordispleasing;thoughthesmellofaroseandviolet,bothsweet,arecertainlyverydistinctideas。
Norarethedifferenttastes,thatbyourpalateswereceiveideasof,muchbetterprovidedwithnames。Sweet,bitter,sour,harsh,andsaltarealmostalltheepithetswehavetodenominatethatnumberlessvarietyofrelishes,whicharetobefounddistinct,notonlyinalmosteverysortofcreatures,butinthedifferentpartsofthesameplant,fruit,oranimal。Thesamemaybesaidofcoloursandsounds。I
shall,therefore,intheaccountofsimpleideasIamheregiving,contentmyselftosetdownonlysuchasaremostmaterialtoourpresentpurpose,orareinthemselveslessapttobetakennoticeofthoughtheyareveryfrequentlytheingredientsofourcomplexideas;amongstwhich,Ithink,Imaywellaccountsolidity,whichthereforeIshalltreatofinthenextchapter。
ChapterIV
IdeaofSolidity1。Wereceivethisideafromtouch。Theideaofsoliditywereceivebyourtouch:anditarisesfromtheresistancewhichwefindinbodytotheentranceofanyotherbodyintotheplaceitpossesses,tillithasleftit。Thereisnoideawhichwereceivemoreconstantlyfromsensationthansolidity。Whetherwemoveorrest,inwhatposturesoeverweare,wealwaysfeelsomethingunderusthatsupportus,andhindersourfurthersinkingdownwards;andthebodieswhichwedailyhandlemakeusperceivethat,whilsttheyremainbetweenthem,theydo,byaninsurmountableforce,hindertheapproachofthepartsofourhandsthatpressthem。Thatwhichthushinderstheapproachoftwobodies,whentheyaremovedonetowardsanother,I
callsolidity。Iwillnotdisputewhetherthisacceptationofthewordsolidbenearertoitsoriginalsignificationthanthatwhichmathematiciansuseitin。ItsufficesthatIthinkthecommonnotionofsoliditywillallow,ifnotjustify,thisuseofit;butifanyonethinkitbettertocallitimpenetrability,hehasmyconsent。OnlyIhavethoughtthetermsoliditythemorepropertoexpressthisidea,notonlybecauseofitsvulgaruseinthatsense,butalsobecauseitcarriessomethingmoreofpositiveinitthanimpenetrability;
whichisnegative,andisperhapsmoreaconsequenceofsolidity,thansolidityitself。This,ofallother,seemstheideamostintimatelyconnectedwith,andessentialtobody;soasnowhereelsetobefoundorimagined,butonlyinmatter。Andthoughoursensestakenonoticeofit,butinmassesofmatter,ofabulksufficienttocauseasensationinus:yetthemind,havingoncegotthisideafromsuchgrossersensiblebodies,tracesitfurther,andconsidersit,aswellasfigure,intheminutestparticleofmatterthatcanexist;andfindsitinseparablyinherentinbody,whereverorhowevermodified。
2。Solidityfillsspace。Thisistheideawhichbelongstobody,wherebyweconceiveittofillspace。Theideaofwhichfillingofspaceis,-thatwhereweimagineanyspacetakenupbyasolidsubstance,weconceiveitsotopossessit,thatitexcludesallothersolidsubstances;andwillforeverhinderanyothertwobodies,thatmovetowardsoneanotherinastraightline,fromcomingtotouchoneanother,unlessitremovesfrombetweentheminalinenotparalleltothatwhichtheymovein。Thisideaofit,thebodieswhichweordinarilyhandlesufficientlyfurnishuswith。
3。Distinctfromspace。Thisresistance,wherebyitkeepsotherbodiesoutofthespacewhichitpossesses,issogreat,thatnoforce,howgreatsoever,cansurmountit。Allthebodiesintheworld,pressingadropofwateronallsides,willneverbeabletoovercometheresistancewhichitwillmake,softasitis,totheirapproachingoneanother,tillitberemovedoutoftheirway:
wherebyourideaofsolidityisdistinguishedbothfrompurespace,whichiscapableneitherofresistancenormotion;andfromtheordinaryideaofhardness。Foramanmayconceivetwobodiesatadistance,soastheymayapproachoneanother,withouttouchingordisplacinganysolidthing,tilltheirsuperficiescometomeet;
whereby,Ithink,wehavetheclearideaofspacewithoutsolidity。
For(nottogosofarasannihilationofanyparticularbody)Iask,whetheramancannothavetheideaofthemotionofonesinglebodyalone,withoutanyothersucceedingimmediatelyintoitsplace?I
thinkitisevidenthecan:theideaofmotioninonebodynomoreincludingtheideaofmotioninanother,thantheideaofasquarefigureinonebodyincludestheideaofasquarefigureinanother。
Idonotask,whetherbodiesdosoexist,thatthemotionofonebodycannotreallybewithoutthemotionofanother。Todeterminethiseitherway,istobegthequestionfororagainstavacuum。Butmyquestionis,-whetheronecannothavetheideaofonebodymoved,whilstothersareatrest?AndIthinkthisnoonewilldeny。Ifso,thentheplaceitdesertedgivesustheideaofpurespacewithoutsolidity;whereintoanyotherbodymayenter,withouteitherresistanceorprotrusionofanything。Whenthesuckerinapumpisdrawn,thespaceitfilledinthetubeiscertainlythesamewhetheranyotherbodyfollowsthemotionofthesuckerornot:nordoesitimplyacontradictionthat,uponthemotionofonebody,anotherthatisonlycontiguoustoitshouldnotfollowit。Thenecessityofsuchamotionisbuiltonlyonthesuppositionthattheworldisfull;
butnotonthedistinctideasofspaceandsolidity,whichareasdifferentasresistanceandnotresistance,protrusionandnotprotrusion。Andthatmenhaveideasofspacewithoutabody,theirverydisputesaboutavacuumplainlydemonstrate,asisshowninanotherplace。
4。Fromhardness。Solidityisherebyalsodifferencedfromhardness,inthatsolidityconsistsinrepletion,andsoanutterexclusionofotherbodiesoutofthespaceitpossesses:buthardness,inafirmcohesionofthepartsofmatter,makingupmassesofasensiblebulk,sothatthewholedoesnoteasilychangeitsfigure。Andindeed,hardandsoftarenamesthatwegivetothingsonlyinrelationtotheconstitutionsofourownbodies;thatbeinggenerallycalledhardbyus,whichwillputustopainsoonerthanchangefigurebythepressureofanypartofourbodies;andthat,onthecontrary,soft,whichchangesthesituationofitspartsuponaneasyandunpainfultouch。
Butthisdifficultyofchangingthesituationofthesensiblepartsamongstthemselves,orofthefigureofthewhole,givesnomoresoliditytothehardestbodyintheworldthantothesoftest;norisanadamantonejotmoresolidthanwater。For,thoughthetwoflatsidesoftwopiecesofmarblewillmoreeasilyapproacheachother,betweenwhichthereisnothingbutwaterorair,thaniftherebeadiamondbetweenthem;yetitisnotthatthepartsofthediamondaremoresolidthanthoseofwater,orresistmore;butbecausethepartsofwater,beingmoreeasilyseparablefromeachother,theywill,byasidemotion,bemoreeasilyremoved,andgivewaytotheapproachofthetwopiecesofmarble。Butiftheycouldbekeptfrommakingplacebythatsidemotion,theywouldeternallyhindertheapproachofthesetwopiecesofmarble,asmuchasthediamond;anditwouldbeasimpossiblebyanyforcetosurmounttheirresistance,astosurmounttheresistanceofthepartsofadiamond。Thesoftestbodyintheworldwillasinvinciblyresistthecomingtogetherofanyothertwobodies,ifitbenotputoutoftheway,butremainbetweenthem,asthehardestthatcanbefoundorimagined。Hethatshallfillayieldingsoftbodywellwithairorwater,willquicklyfinditsresistance。Andhethatthinksthatnothingbutbodiesthatarehardcankeephishandsfromapproachingoneanother,maybepleasedtomakeatrial,withtheairinclosedinafootball。Theexperiment,Ihavebeentold,wasmadeatFlorence,withahollowglobeofgoldfilledwithwater,andexactlyclosed;
whichfurthershowsthesolidityofsosoftabodyaswater。Forthegoldenglobethusfilled,beingputintoapress,whichwasdrivenbytheextremeforceofscrews,thewatermadeitselfwaythroughtheporesofthatveryclosemetal,andfindingnoroomforanearerapproachofitsparticleswithin,gottotheoutside,whereitroselikeadew,andsofellindrops,beforethesidesoftheglobecouldbemadetoyieldtotheviolentcompressionoftheenginethatsqueezedit。
5。Onsoliditydependimpulse,resistance,andprotrusion。Bythisideaofsolidityistheextensionofbodydistinguishedfromtheextensionofspace:-theextensionofbodybeingnothingbutthecohesionorcontinuityofsolid,separable,movableparts;andtheextensionofspace,thecontinuityofunsolid,inseparable,andimmovableparts。Uponthesolidityofbodiesalsodependtheirmutualimpulse,resistance,andprotrusion。Ofpurespacethen,andsolidity,thereareseveral(amongstwhichIconfessmyselfone)whopersuadethemselvestheyhaveclearanddistinctideas;andthattheycanthinkonspace,withoutanythinginitthatresistsorisprotrudedbybody。Thisistheideaofpurespace,whichtheythinktheyhaveasclearasanyideatheycanhaveoftheextensionofbody:
theideaofthedistancebetweentheoppositepartsofaconcavesuperficiesbeingequallyasclearwithoutaswiththeideaofanysolidpartsbetween:andontheotherside,theypersuadethemselvesthattheyhave,distinctfromthatofpurespace,theideaofsomethingthatfillsspace,thatcanbeprotrudedbytheimpulseofotherbodies,orresisttheirmotion。Iftherebeothersthathavenotthesetwoideasdistinct,butconfoundthem,andmakebutoneofthem,Iknownothowmen,whohavethesameideaunderdifferentnames,ordifferentideasunderthesamename,caninthatcasetalkwithoneanother;anymorethanamanwho,notbeingblindordeaf,hasdistinctideasofthecolourofscarletandthesoundofatrumpet,coulddiscourseconcerningscarletcolourwiththeblindmanI
mentionedinanotherplace,whofanciedthattheideaofscarletwaslikethesoundofatrumpet。
6。Whatsolidityis。Ifanyoneaskme,Whatthissolidityis,I
sendhimtohissensestoinformhim。Lethimputaflintorafootballbetweenhishands,andthenendeavourtojointhem,andhewillknow。Ifhethinksthisnotasufficientexplicationofsolidity,whatitis,andwhereinitconsists;Ipromisetotellhimwhatitis,andwhereinitconsists,whenhetellsmewhatthinkingis,orwhereinitconsists;orexplainstomewhatextensionormotionis,whichperhapsseemsmucheasier。Thesimpleideaswehave,aresuchasexperienceteachesthemus;butif,beyondthat,weendeavourbywordstomakethemclearerinthemind,weshallsucceednobetterthanifwewentabouttoclearupthedarknessofablindman’smindbytalking;andtodiscourseintohimtheideasoflightandcolours。ThereasonofthisIshallshowinanotherplace。
ChapterV
OfSimpleIdeasofDiversSensesIdeasreceivedbothbyseeingandtouching。Theideaswegetbymorethanonesenseare,ofspaceorextension,figure,rest,andmotion。
Forthesemakeperceivableimpressions,bothontheeyesandtouch;
andwecanreceiveandconveyintoourmindstheideasoftheextension,figure,motion,andrestofbodies,bothbyseeingandfeeling。Buthavingoccasiontospeakmoreatlargeoftheseinanotherplace,Ihereonlyenumeratethem。
ChapterVI
OfSimpleIdeasofReflection1。Simpleideasaretheoperationsofmindaboutitsotherideas。Themindreceivingtheideasmentionedintheforegoingchaptersfromwithout,whenitturnsitsviewinwarduponitself,andobservesitsownactionsaboutthoseideasithas,takesfromthenceotherideas,whichareascapabletobetheobjectsofitscontemplationasanyofthoseitreceivedfromforeignthings。
2。Theideaofperception,andideaofwilling,wehavefromreflection。Thetwogreatandprincipalactionsofthemind,whicharemostfrequentlyconsidered,andwhicharesofrequentthateveryonethatpleasesmaytakenoticeoftheminhimself,arethesetwo:-
Perception,orThinking;andVolition,orWilling。
ThepowerofthinkingiscalledtheUnderstanding,andthepowerofvolitioniscalledtheWill;andthesetwopowersorabilitiesinthemindaredenominatedfaculties。
Ofsomeofthemodesofthesesimpleideasofreflection,suchasareremembrance,discerning,reasoning,judging,knowledge,faith,&c。,Ishallhaveoccasiontospeakhereafter。
ChapterVII
OfSimpleIdeasofbothSensationandReflection1。Ideasofpleasureandpain。Therebeothersimpleideaswhichconveythemselvesintothemindbyallthewaysofsensationandreflection,viz。pleasureordelight,anditsopposite,pain,oruneasiness;power;existence;unity。
2。Mixwithalmostallourotherideas。Delightoruneasiness,oneorotherofthem,jointhemselvestoalmostallourideasbothofsensationandreflection:andthereisscarceanyaffectionofoursensesfromwithout,anyretiredthoughtofourmindwithin,whichisnotabletoproduceinuspleasureorpain。Bypleasureandpain,I
wouldbeunderstoodtosignify,whatsoeverdelightsormolestsus;
whetheritarisesfromthethoughtsofourminds,oranythingoperatingonourbodies。For,whetherwecallitsatisfaction,delight,pleasure,happiness,&c。,ontheoneside,oruneasiness,trouble,pain,torment,anguish,misery,&c。,ontheother,theyarestillbutdifferentdegreesofthesamething,andbelongtotheideasofpleasureandpain,delightoruneasiness;whicharethenamesI
shallmostcommonlyuseforthosetwosortsofideas。
3。Asmotivesofouractions。TheinfinitewiseAuthorofourbeing,havinggivenusthepoweroverseveralpartsofourbodies,tomoveorkeepthematrestaswethinkfit;andalso。bythemotionofthem,tomoveourselvesandothercontiguousbodies,inwhichconsistalltheactionsofourbody:havingalsogivenapowertoourminds,inseveralinstances,tochoose,amongstitsideas,whichitwillthinkon,andtopursuetheinquiryofthisorthatsubjectwithconsiderationandattention,toexciteustotheseactionsofthinkingandmotionthatwearecapableof,-hasbeenpleasedtojointoseveralthoughts,andseveralsensationsaperceptionofdelight。Ifthiswerewhollyseparatedfromallouroutwardsensations,andinwardthoughts,weshouldhavenoreasontopreferonethoughtoractiontoanother;negligencetoattention,ormotiontorest。Andsoweshouldneitherstirourbodies,noremployourminds,butletourthoughts(ifImaysocallit)runadrift,withoutanydirectionordesign,andsuffertheideasofourminds,likeunregardedshadows,tomaketheirappearancesthere,asithappened,withoutattendingtothem。Inwhichstateman,howeverfurnishedwiththefacultiesofunderstandingandwill,wouldbeaveryidle,inactivecreature,andpasshistimeonlyinalazy,lethargicdream。IthasthereforepleasedourwiseCreatortoannextoseveralobjects,andtheideaswhichwereceivefromthem,asalsotoseveralofourthoughts,aconcomitantpleasure,andthatinseveralobjects,toseveraldegrees,thatthosefacultieswhichhehadendoweduswithmightnotremainwhollyidleandunemployedbyus。
4。Anendanduseofpain。Painhasthesameefficacyandusetosetusonworkthatpleasurehas,webeingasreadytoemployourfacultiestoavoidthat,astopursuethis:onlythisisworthourconsideration,thatpainisoftenproducedbythesameobjectsandideasthatproducepleasureinus。Thistheirnearconjunction,whichmakesusoftenfeelpaininthesensationswhereweexpectedpleasure,givesusnewoccasionofadmiringthewisdomandgoodnessofourMaker,who,designingthepreservationofourbeing,hasannexedpaintotheapplicationofmanythingstoourbodies,towarnusoftheharmthattheywilldo,andasadvicestowithdrawfromthem。
Buthe,notdesigningourpreservationbarely,butthepreservationofeverypartandorganinitsperfection,hathinmanycasesannexedpaintothoseveryideaswhichdelightus。Thusheat,thatisveryagreeabletousinonedegree,byalittlegreaterincreaseofitprovesnoordinarytorment:andthemostpleasantofallsensibleobjects,lightitself,iftherebetoomuchofit,ifincreasedbeyondadueproportiontooureyes,causesaverypainfulsensation。Whichiswiselyandfavourablysoorderedbynature,thatwhenanyobjectdoes,bythevehemencyofitsoperation,disordertheinstrumentsofsensation,whosestructurescannotbutbeveryniceanddelicate,wemight,bythepain,bewarnedtowithdraw,beforetheorganbequiteputoutoforder,andsobeunfittedforitsproperfunctionforthefuture。Theconsiderationofthoseobjectsthatproduceitmaywellpersuadeus,thatthisistheendoruseofpain。For,thoughgreatlightbeinsufferabletooureyes,yetthehighestdegreeofdarknessdoesnotatalldiseasethem:becausethat,causingnodisorderlymotioninit,leavesthatcuriousorganunharmedinitsnaturalstate。Butyetexcessofcoldaswellasheatpainsus:
becauseitisequallydestructivetothattemperwhichisnecessarytothepreservationoflife,andtheexerciseoftheseveralfunctionsofthebody,andwhichconsistsinamoderatedegreeofwarmth;or,ifyouplease,amotionoftheinsensiblepartsofourbodies,confinedwithincertainbounds。
5。Anotherend。Beyondallthis,wemayfindanotherreasonwhyGodhathscatteredupanddownseveraldegreesofpleasureandpain,inallthethingsthatenvironandaffectus;andblendedthemtogetherinalmostallthatourthoughtsandsenseshavetodowith;-thatwe,findingimperfection,dissatisfaction,andwantofcompletehappiness,inalltheenjoymentswhichthecreaturescanaffordus,mightbeledtoseekitintheenjoymentofHimwithwhomthereisfullnessofjoy,andatwhoserighthandarepleasuresforevermore。
6。GoodnessofGodinannexingpleasureandpaintoourotherideas。
ThoughwhatIhaveheresaidmaynot,perhaps,maketheideasofpleasureandpainclearertousthanourownexperiencedoes,whichistheonlywaythatwearecapableofhavingthem;yettheconsiderationofthereasonwhytheyareannexedtosomanyotherideas,servingtogiveusduesentimentsofthewisdomandgoodnessoftheSovereignDisposerofallthings,maynotbeunsuitabletothemainendoftheseinquiries:theknowledgeandvenerationofhimbeingthechiefendofallourthoughts,andtheproperbusinessofallunderstandings。
7。Ideasofexistenceandunity。ExistenceandUnityaretwootherideasthataresuggestedtotheunderstandingbyeveryobjectwithout,andeveryideawithin。Whenideasareinourminds,weconsiderthemasbeingactuallythere,aswellasweconsiderthingstobeactuallywithoutus;-whichis,thattheyexist,orhaveexistence。
Andwhateverwecanconsiderasonething,whetherarealbeingoridea,suggeststotheunderstandingtheideaofunity。
8。Ideaofpower。Poweralsoisanotherofthosesimpleideaswhichwereceivefromsensationandreflection。For,observinginourselvesthatwedoandcanthink,andthatwecanatpleasuremoveseveralpartsofourbodieswhichwereatrest;theeffects,also,thatnaturalbodiesareabletoproduceinoneanother,occurringeverymomenttooursenses,-weboththesewaysgettheideaofpower。
9。Ideaofsuccession。Besidesthesethereisanotheridea,which,thoughsuggestedbyoursenses,yetismoreconstantlyofferedtousbywhatpassesinourminds;andthatistheideaofsuccession。Forifwelookimmediatelyintoourselves,andreflectonwhatisobservablethere,weshallfindourideasalways,whilstweareawake,orhaveanythought,passingintrain,onegoingandanothercoming,withoutintermission。
10。Simpleideasthematerialsofallourknowledge。These,iftheyarenotall,areatleast(asIthink)themostconsiderableofthosesimpleideaswhichthemindhas,andoutofwhichismadeallitsotherknowledge;allwhichitreceivesonlybythetwoforementionedwaysofsensationandreflection。
Norletanyonethinkthesetoonarrowboundsforthecapaciousmindofmantoexpatiatein,whichtakesitsflightfurtherthanthestars,andcannotbeconfinedbythelimitsoftheworld;thatextendsitsthoughtsoftenevenbeyondtheutmostexpansionofMatter,andmakesexcursionsintothatincomprehensibleInane。Igrantallthis,butdesireanyonetoassignanysimpleideawhichisnotreceivedfromoneofthoseinletsbeforementioned,oranycomplexideanotmadeoutofthosesimpleones。Norwillitbesostrangetothinkthesefewsimpleideassufficienttoemploythequickestthought,orlargestcapacity;andtofurnishthematerialsofallthatvariousknowledge,andmorevariousfanciesandopinionsofallmankind,ifweconsiderhowmanywordsmaybemadeoutofthevariouscompositionoftwenty-fourletters;orif,goingonestepfurther,wewillbutreflectonthevarietyofcombinationsthatmaybemadewithbarelyoneoftheabove-mentionedideas,viz。number,whosestockisinexhaustibleandtrulyinfinite:andwhatalargeandimmensefielddothextensionaloneaffordthemathematicians?
ChapterVIII
SomefurtherconsiderationsconcerningourSimpleIdeasofSensation1。Positiveideasfromprivativecauses。ConcerningthesimpleideasofSensation,itistobeconsidered,-thatwhatsoeverissoconstitutedinnatureastobeable,byaffectingoursenses,tocauseanyperceptioninthemind,doththerebyproduceintheunderstandingasimpleidea;which,whateverbetheexternalcauseofit,whenitcomestobetakennoticeofbyourdiscerningfaculty,itisbythemindlookedonandconsideredtheretobearealpositiveideaintheunderstanding,asmuchasanyotherwhatsoever;
though,perhaps,thecauseofitbebutaprivationofthesubject。
2。Ideasintheminddistinguishedfromthatinthingswhichgivesrisetothem。Thustheideasofheatandcold,lightanddarkness,whiteandblack,motionandrest,areequallyclearandpositiveideasinthemind;though,perhaps,someofthecauseswhichproducethemarebarelyprivations,inthosesubjectsfromwhenceoursensesderivethoseideas。Thesetheunderstanding,initsviewofthem,considersallasdistinctpositiveideas,withouttakingnoticeofthecausesthatproducethem:whichisaninquirynotbelongingtotheidea,asitisintheunderstanding,buttothenatureofthethingsexistingwithoutus。Thesearetwoverydifferentthings,andcarefullytobedistinguished;itbeingonethingtoperceiveandknowtheideaofwhiteorblack,andquiteanothertoexaminewhatkindofparticlestheymustbe,andhowrangedinthesuperficies,tomakeanyobjectappearwhiteorblack。
3。Wemayhavetheideaswhenweareignorantoftheirphysicalcauses。Apainterordyerwhoneverinquiredintotheircauseshaththeideasofwhiteandblack,andothercolours,asclearly,perfectly,anddistinctlyinhisunderstanding,andperhapsmoredistinctly,thanthephilosopherwhohathbusiedhimselfinconsideringtheirnatures,andthinksheknowshowfareitherofthemis,initscause,positiveorprivative;andtheideaofblackisnolesspositiveinhismindthanthatofwhite,howeverthecauseofthatcolourintheexternalobjectmaybeonlyaprivation。
4。Whyaprivativecauseinnaturemayoccasionapositiveidea。
Ifitwerethedesignofmypresentundertakingtoinquireintothenaturalcausesandmannerofperception,Ishouldofferthisasareasonwhyaprivativecausemight,insomecasesatleast,produceapositiveidea;viz。thatallsensationbeingproducedinusonlybydifferentdegreesandmodesofmotioninouranimalspirits,variouslyagitatedbyexternalobjects,theabatementofanyformermotionmustasnecessarilyproduceanewsensationasthevariationorincreaseofit;andsointroduceanewidea,whichdependsonlyonadifferentmotionoftheanimalspiritsinthatorgan。
5。Negativenamesneednotbemeaningless。ButwhetherthisbesoornotIwillnotheredetermine,butappealtoeveryone’sownexperience,whethertheshadowofaman,thoughitconsistsofnothingbuttheabsenceoflight(andthemoretheabsenceoflightis,themorediscernibleistheshadow)doesnot,whenamanlooksonit,causeasclearandpositiveideainhismindasamanhimself,thoughcoveredoverwithclearsunshine?Andthepictureofashadowisapositivething。Indeed,wehavenegativenames,whichstandnotdirectlyforpositiveideas,butfortheirabsence,suchasinsipid,silence,nihil,&c。;whichwordsdenotepositiveideas,v。g。taste,sound,being,withasignificationoftheirabsence。
6。Whetheranyideasareduetocausesreallyprivative。Andthusonemaytrulybesaidtoseedarkness。For,supposingaholeperfectlydark,fromwhencenolightisreflected,itiscertainonemayseethefigureofit,oritmaybepainted;orwhethertheinkIwritewithmakesanyotheridea,isaquestion。TheprivativecausesIhavehereassignedofpositiveideasareaccordingtothecommonopinion;
but,intruth,itwillbehardtodeterminewhethertherebereallyanyideasfromaprivativecause,tillitbedetermined,whetherrestbeanymoreaprivationthanmotion。
7。Ideasinthemind,qualitiesinbodies。Todiscoverthenatureofourideasthebetter,andtodiscourseofthemintelligibly,itwillbeconvenienttodistinguishthemastheyareideasorperceptionsinourminds;andastheyaremodificationsofmatterinthebodiesthatcausesuchperceptionsinus:thatsowemaynotthink(asperhapsusuallyisdone)thattheyareexactlytheimagesandresemblancesofsomethinginherentinthesubject;mostofthoseofsensationbeinginthemindnomorethelikenessofsomethingexistingwithoutus,thanthenamesthatstandforthemarethelikenessofourideas,whichyetuponhearingtheyareapttoexciteinus。
8。Ourideasandthequalitiesofbodies。Whatsoeverthemindperceivesinitself,oristheimmediateobjectofperception,thought,orunderstanding,thatIcallidea;andthepowertoproduceanyideainourmind,Icallqualityofthesubjectwhereinthatpoweris。Thusasnowballhavingthepowertoproduceinustheideasofwhite,cold,andround,-thepowertoproducethoseideasinus,astheyareinthesnowball,Icallqualities;andastheyaresensationsorperceptionsinourunderstandings,Icallthemideas;whichideas,ifIspeakofsometimesasinthethingsthemselves,Iwouldbeunderstoodtomeanthosequalitiesintheobjectswhichproducetheminus。
9。Primaryqualitiesofbodies。Qualitiesthusconsideredinbodiesare,First,suchasareutterlyinseparablefromthebody,inwhatstatesoeveritbe;andsuchasinallthealterationsandchangesitsuffers,alltheforcecanbeuseduponit,itconstantlykeeps;
andsuchassenseconstantlyfindsineveryparticleofmatterwhichhasbulkenoughtobeperceived;andthemindfindsinseparablefromeveryparticleofmatter,thoughlessthantomakeitselfsinglybeperceivedbyoursenses:v。g。Takeagrainofwheat,divideitintotwoparts;eachparthasstillsolidity,extension,figure,andmobility:divideitagain,anditretainsstillthesamequalities;
andsodivideiton,tillthepartsbecomeinsensible;theymustretainstilleachofthemallthosequalities。Fordivision(whichisallthatamill,orpestle,oranyotherbody,doesuponanother,inreducingittoinsensibleparts)cannevertakeawayeithersolidity,extension,figure,ormobilityfromanybody,butonlymakestwoormoredistinctseparatemassesofmatter,ofthatwhichwasbutonebefore;allwhichdistinctmasses,reckonedassomanydistinctbodies,afterdivision,makeacertainnumber。TheseIcalloriginalorprimaryqualitiesofbody,whichIthinkwemayobservetoproducesimpleideasinus,viz。solidity,extension,figure,motionorrest,andnumber。
10。Secondaryqualitiesofbodies。Secondly,suchqualitieswhichintrutharenothingintheobjectsthemselvesbutpowertoproducevarioussensationsinusbytheirprimaryqualities,i。e。bythebulk,figure,texture,andmotionoftheirinsensibleparts,ascolours,sounds,tastes,&c。TheseIcallsecondaryqualities。Tothesemightbeaddedathirdsort,whichareallowedtobebarelypowers;thoughtheyareasmuchrealqualitiesinthesubjectasthosewhichI,tocomplywiththecommonwayofspeaking,callqualities,butfordistinction,secondaryqualities。Forthepowerinfiretoproduceanewcolour,orconsistency,inwaxorclay,-byitsprimaryqualities,isasmuchaqualityinfire,asthepowerithastoproduceinmeanewideaorsensationofwarmthorburning,whichIfeltnotbefore,-bythesameprimaryqualities,viz。thebulk,texture,andmotionofitsinsensibleparts。
11。Howbodiesproduceideasinus。Thenextthingtobeconsideredis,howbodiesproduceideasinus;andthatismanifestlybyimpulse,theonlywaywhichwecanconceivebodiestooperatein。
12。Bymotions,external,andinourorganism。Ifthenexternalobjectsbenotunitedtoourmindswhentheyproduceideastherein;
andyetweperceivetheseoriginalqualitiesinsuchofthemassinglyfallunderoursenses,itisevidentthatsomemotionmustbethencecontinuedbyournerves,oranimalspirits,bysomepartsofourbodies,tothebrainsortheseatofsensation,theretoproduceinourmindstheparticularideaswehaveofthem。Andsincetheextension,figure,number,andmotionofbodiesofanobservablebigness,maybeperceivedatadistancebythesight,itisevidentsomesinglyimperceptiblebodiesmustcomefromthemtotheeyes,andtherebyconveytothebrainsomemotion;whichproducestheseideaswhichwehaveoftheminus。
13。Howsecondaryqualitiesproducetheirideas。Afterthesamemanner,thattheideasoftheseoriginalqualitiesareproducedinus,wemayconceivethattheideasofsecondaryqualitiesarealsoproduced,viz。bytheoperationofinsensibleparticlesonoursenses。
For,itbeingmanifestthattherearebodiesandgoodstoreofbodies,eachwhereofaresosmall,thatwecannotbyanyofoursensesdiscovereithertheirbulk,figure,ormotion,-asisevidentintheparticlesoftheairandwater,andothersextremelysmallerthanthose;perhapsasmuchsmallerthantheparticlesofairandwater,astheparticlesofairandwateraresmallerthanpeasorhail-stones;-letussupposeatpresentthatthedifferentmotionsandfigures,bulkandnumber,ofsuchparticles,affectingtheseveralorgansofoursenses,produceinusthosedifferentsensationswhichwehavefromthecoloursandsmellsofbodies;v。g。thataviolet,bytheimpulseofsuchinsensibleparticlesofmatter,ofpeculiarfiguresandbulks,andindifferentdegreesandmodificationsoftheirmotions,causestheideasofthebluecolour,andsweetscentofthatflowertobeproducedinourminds。ItbeingnomoreimpossibletoconceivethatGodshouldannexsuchideastosuchmotions,withwhichtheyhavenosimilitude,thanthatheshouldannextheideaofpaintothemotionofapieceofsteeldividingourflesh,withwhichthatideahathnoresemblance。
14。Theydependontheprimaryqualities。WhatIhavesaidconcerningcoloursandsmellsmaybeunderstoodalsooftastesandsounds,andotherthelikesensiblequalities;which,whateverrealitywebymistakeattributetothem,areintruthnothingintheobjectsthemselves,butpowerstoproducevarioussensationsinus;anddependonthoseprimaryqualities,viz。bulk,figure,texture,andmotionofpartsasIhavesaid。
15。Ideasofprimaryqualitiesareresemblances;ofsecondary,not。FromwhenceIthinkiteasytodrawthisobservation,-thattheideasofprimaryqualitiesofbodiesareresemblancesofthem,andtheirpatternsdoreallyexistinthebodiesthemselves,buttheideasproducedinusbythesesecondaryqualitieshavenoresemblanceofthematall。Thereisnothinglikeourideas,existinginthebodiesthemselves。Theyare,inthebodieswedenominatefromthem,onlyapowertoproducethosesensationsinus:andwhatissweet,blue,orwarminidea,isbutthecertainbulk,figure,andmotionoftheinsensibleparts,inthebodiesthemselves,whichwecallso。
16。Examples。Flameisdenominatedhotandlight;snow,whiteandcold;andmanna,whiteandsweet,fromtheideastheyproduceinus。
Whichqualitiesarecommonlythoughttobethesameinthosebodiesthatthoseideasareinus,theonetheperfectresemblanceoftheother,astheyareinamirror,anditwouldbymostmenbejudgedveryextravagantifoneshouldsayotherwise。Andyethethatwillconsiderthatthesamefirethat,atonedistanceproducesinusthesensationofwarmth,does,atanearerapproach,produceinusthefardifferentsensationofpain,oughttobethinkhimselfwhatreasonhehastosay-thatthisideaofwarmth,whichwasproducedinhimbythefire,isactuallyinthefire;andhisideaofpain,whichthesamefireproducedinhimthesameway,isnotinthefire。Whyarewhitenessandcoldnessinsnow,andpainnot,whenitproducestheoneandtheotherideainus;andcandoneither,butbythebulk,figure,number,andmotionofitssolidparts?
17。Theideasoftheprimaryalonereallyexist。Theparticularbulk,number,figure,andmotionofthepartsoffireorsnowarereallyinthem,-whetheranyone’ssensesperceivethemorno:andthereforetheymaybecalledrealqualities,becausetheyreallyexistinthosebodies。Butlight,heat,whiteness,orcoldness,arenomorereallyinthemthansicknessorpainisinmanna。Takeawaythesensationofthem;letnottheeyesseelightorcolours,northeearshearsounds;letthepalatenottaste,northenosesmell,andallcolours,tastes,odours,andsounds,astheyaresuchparticularideas,vanishandcease,andarereducedtotheircauses,i。e。bulk,figure,andmotionofparts。
18。Thesecondaryexistinthingsonlyasmodesoftheprimary。A
pieceofmannaofasensiblebulkisabletoproduceinustheideaofaroundorsquarefigure;andbybeingremovedfromoneplacetoanother,theideaofmotion。Thisideaofmotionrepresentsitasitreallyisinmannamoving:acircleorsquarearethesame,whetherinideaorexistence,inthemindorinthemanna。Andthis,bothmotionandfigure,arereallyinthemanna,whetherwetakenoticeofthemorno:thiseverybodyisreadytoagreeto。Besides,manna,bytiebulk,figure,texture,andmotionofitsparts,hasapowertoproducethesensationsofsickness,andsometimesofacutepainsorgripingsinus。Thattheseideasofsicknessandpainarenotinthemanna,buteffectsofitsoperationsonus,andarenowherewhenwefeelthemnot;thisalsoeveryonereadilyagreesto。Andyetmenarehardlytobebroughttothinkthatsweetnessandwhitenessarenotreallyinmanna;whicharebuttheeffectsoftheoperationsofmanna,bythemotion,size,andfigureofitsparticles,ontheeyesandpalate:asthepainandsicknesscausedbymannaareconfessedlynothingbuttheeffectsofitsoperationsonthestomachandguts,bythesize,motion,andfigureofitsinsensibleparts,(forbynothingelsecanabodyoperate,ashasbeenproved):asifitcouldnotoperateontheeyesandpalate,andtherebyproduceinthemindparticulardistinctideas,whichinitselfithasnot,aswellasweallowitcanoperateonthegutsandstomach,andtherebyproducedistinctideas,whichinitselfithasnot。Theseideas,beingalleffectsoftheoperationsofmannaonseveralpartsofourbodies,bythesize,figurenumber,andmotionofitsparts;-whythoseproducedbytheeyesandpalateshouldratherbethoughttobereallyinthemanna,thanthoseproducedbythestomachandguts;orwhythepainandsickness,ideasthataretheeffectofmanna,shouldbethoughttobenowherewhentheyarenotfelt;andyetthesweetnessandwhiteness,effectsofthesamemannaonotherpartsofthebody,bywaysequallyasunknown,shouldbethoughttoexistinthemanna,whentheyarenotseenortasted,wouldneedsomereasontoexplain。
19。Examples。Letusconsidertheredandwhitecoloursinporphyry。
Hinderlightfromstrikingonit,anditscoloursvanish;itnolongerproducesanysuchideasinus:uponthereturnoflightitproducestheseappearancesonusagain。Cananyonethinkanyrealalterationsaremadeintheporphyrybythepresenceorabsenceoflight;andthatthoseideasofwhitenessandrednessarereallyinporphyryin。thelight,whenitisplainithasnocolourinthedark?
Ithas,indeed,suchaconfigurationofparticles,bothnightandday,asareapt,bytheraysoflightreboundingfromsomepartsofthathardstone,toproduceinustheideaofredness,andfromotherstheideaofwhiteness;butwhitenessorrednessarenotinitatanytime,butsuchatexturethathaththepowertoproducesuchasensationinus。
20。Poundanalmond,andtheclearwhitecolourwillbealteredintoadirtyone,andthesweettasteintoanoilyone。Whatrealalterationcanthebeatingofthepestlemakeinanybody,butanalterationofthetextureofit?
21。Explainshowwaterfeltascoldbyonehandmaybewarmtotheother。Ideasbeingthusdistinguishedandunderstood,wemaybeabletogiveanaccounthowthesamewater,atthesametime,mayproducetheideaofcoldbyonehandandofheatbytheother:whereasitisimpossiblethatthesamewater,ifthoseideaswerereallyinit,shouldatthesametimebebothhotandcold。For,ifweimaginewarmth,asitisinourhands,tobenothingbutacertainsortanddegreeofmotionintheminuteparticlesofournervesoranimalspirits,wemayunderstandhowitispossiblethatthesamewatermay,atthesametime,producethesensationsofheatinonehandandcoldintheother;whichyetfigureneverdoes,thatneverproducing-theideaofasquarebyonehandwhichhasproducedtheideaofaglobebyanother。Butifthesensationofheatandcoldbenothingbuttheincreaseordiminutionofthemotionoftheminutepartsofourbodies,causedbythecorpusclesofanyotherbody,itiseasytobeunderstood,thatifthatmotionbegreaterinonehandthanintheother;ifabodybeappliedtothetwohands,whichhasinitsminuteparticlesagreatermotionthaninthoseofoneofthehands,andalessthaninthoseoftheother,itwillincreasethemotionoftheonehandandlessenitintheother;andsocausethedifferentsensationsofheatandcoldthatdependthereon。
22。Anexcursionintonaturalphilosophy。IhaveinwhatjustgoesbeforebeenengagedinphysicalinquiriesalittlefurtherthanperhapsIintended。But,itbeingnecessarytomakethenatureofsensationalittleunderstood;andtomakethedifferencebetweenthequalitiesinbodies,andtheideasproducedbytheminthemind,tobedistinctlyconceived,withoutwhichitwereimpossibletodiscourseintelligiblyofthem;-IhopeIshallbepardonedthislittleexcursionintonaturalphilosophy;itbeingnecessaryinourpresentinquirytodistinguishtheprimaryandrealqualitiesofbodies,whicharealwaysinthem(viz。solidity,extension,figure,number,andmotion,orrest,andaresometimesperceivedbyus,viz。
whenthebodiestheyareinarebigenoughsinglytobediscerned),fromthosesecondaryandimputedqualities,whicharebutthepowersofseveralcombinationsofthoseprimaryones,whentheyoperatewithoutbeingdistinctlydiscerned;-wherebywemayalsocometoknowwhatideasare,andwhatarenot,resemblancesofsomethingreallyexistinginthebodieswedenominatefromthem。
23。Threesortsofqualitiesinbodies。Thequalities,then,thatareinbodies,rightlyconsidered,areofthreesorts:-
First,Thebulk,figure,number,situation,andmotionorrestoftheirsolidparts。Thoseareinthem,whetherweperceivethemornot;
andwhentheyareofthatsizethatwecandiscoverthem,wehavebytheseanideaofthethingasitisinitself;asisplaininartificialthings。TheseIcallprimaryqualities。
Secondly,Thepowerthatisinanybody,byreasonofitsinsensibleprimaryqualities,tooperateafterapeculiarmanneronanyofoursenses,andtherebyproduceinusthedifferentideasofseveralcolours,sounds,smells,tastes,&c。Theseareusuallycalledsensiblequalities。
Thirdly,Thepowerthatisinanybody,byreasonoftheparticularconstitutionofitsprimaryqualities,tomakesuchachangeinthebulk,figure,texture,andmotionofanotherbody,astomakeitoperateonoursensesdifferentlyfromwhatitdidbefore。
Thusthesunhasapowertomakewaxwhite,andfiretomakeleadfluid。Theseareusuallycalledpowers。
Thefirstofthese,ashasbeensaid,Ithinkmaybeproperlycalledreal,original,orprimaryqualities;becausetheyareinthethingsthemselves,whethertheyareperceivedornot:andupontheirdifferentmodificationsitisthatthesecondaryqualitiesdepend。
Theothertwoareonlypowerstoactdifferentlyuponotherthings:whichpowersresultfromthedifferentmodificationsofthoseprimaryqualities。
24。Thefirstareresemblances;thesecondthoughttoberesemblances,butarenot;thethirdneitherarenorarethoughtso。
But,thoughthetwolattersortsofqualitiesarepowersbarely,andnothingbutpowers,relatingtoseveralotherbodies,andresultingfromthedifferentmodificationsoftheoriginalqualities,yettheyaregenerallyotherwisethoughtof。Forthesecondsort,viz,thepowerstoproduceseveralideasinus,byoursenses,arelookeduponasrealqualitiesinthethingsthusaffectingus:butthethirdsortarecalledandesteemedbarelypowers。v。g。Theideaofheatorlight,whichwereceivebyoureyes,ortouch,fromthesun,arecommonlythoughtrealqualitiesexistinginthesun,andsomethingmorethanmerepowersinit。Butwhenweconsiderthesuninreferencetowax,whichitmeltsorblanches,welookonthewhitenessandsoftnessproducedinthewax,notasqualitiesinthesun,buteffectsproducedbypowersinit。Whereas,ifrightlyconsidered,thesequalitiesoflightandwarmth,whichareperceptionsinmewhenIamwarmedorenlightenedbythesun,arenootherwiseinthesun,thanthechangesmadeinthewax,whenitisblanchedormelted,areinthesun。Theyareallofthemequallypowersinthesun,dependingonitsprimaryqualities;wherebyitisable,intheonecase,sotoalterthebulk,figure,texture,ormotionofsomeoftheinsensiblepartsofmyeyesorhands,astherebytoproduceinmetheideaoflightorheat;andintheother,itisablesotoalterthebulk,figure,texture,ormotionoftheinsensiblepartsofthewax,astomakethemfittoproduceinmethedistinctideasofwhiteandfluid。
25。Whythesecondaryareordinarilytakenforrealqualities,andnotforbarepowers。Thereasonwhytheoneareordinarilytakenforrealqualities,andtheotheronlyforbarepowers,seemstobe,becausetheideaswehaveofdistinctcolours,sounds,&c。,containingnothingatallinthemofbulk,figure,ormotion,wearenotapttothinkthemtheeffectsoftheseprimaryqualities;whichappearnot,tooursenses,tooperateintheirproduction,andwithwhichtheyhavenotanyapparentcongruityorconceivableconnexion。Henceitisthatwearesoforwardtoimagine,thatthoseideasaretheresemblancesofsomethingreallyexistingintheobjectsthemselves:
sincesensationdiscoversnothingofbulk,figure,ormotionofpartsintheirproduction;norcanreasonshowhowbodies,bytheirbulk,figure,andmotion,shouldproduceinthemindtheideasofblueoryellow,&c。But,intheothercase,intheoperationsofbodieschangingthequalitiesoneofanother,weplainlydiscoverthatthequalityproducedhathcommonlynoresemblancewithanythinginthethingproducingit;whereforewelookonitasabareeffectofpower。
For,throughreceivingtheideaofheatorlightfromthesun,weareapttothinkitisaperceptionandresemblanceofsuchaqualityinthesun;yetwhenweseewax,orafairface,receivechangeofcolourfromthesun,wecannotimaginethattobethereceptionorresemblanceofanythinginthesun,becausewefindnotthosedifferentcoloursinthesunitself。For,oursensesbeingabletoobservealikenessorunlikenessofsensiblequalitiesintwodifferentexternalobjects,weforwardlyenoughconcludetheproductionofanysensiblequalityinanysubjecttobeaneffectofbarepower,andnotthecommunicationofanyqualitywhichwasreallyintheefficient,whenwefindnosuchsensiblequalityinthethingthatproducedit。Butoursenses,notbeingabletodiscoveranyunlikenessbetweentheideaproducedinus,andthequalityoftheobjectproducingit,weareapttoimaginethatourideasareresemblancesofsomethingintheobjects,andnottheeffectsofcertainpowersplacedinthemodificationoftheirprimaryqualities,withwhichprimaryqualitiestheideasproducedinushavenoresemblance。
26。Secondaryqualitiestwofold;first,immediatelyperceivable;
secondly,mediatelyperceivable。Toconclude。Besidesthosebefore-mentionedprimaryqualitiesinbodies,viz。bulk,figure,extension,number,andmotionoftheirsolidparts;alltherest,wherebywetakenoticeofbodies,anddistinguishthemonefromanother,arenothingelsebutseveralpowersinthem,dependingonthoseprimaryqualities;wherebytheyarefitted,eitherbyimmediatelyoperatingonourbodiestoproduceseveraldifferentideasinus;orelse,byoperatingonotherbodies,sotochangetheirprimaryqualitiesastorenderthemcapableofproducingideasinusdifferentfromwhatbeforetheydid。Theformerofthese,Ithink,maybecalledsecondaryqualitiesimmediatelyperceivable:thelatter,secondaryqualities,mediatelyperceivable。